Smart Choice Insurance of NY - Staten Island (NY)

Bridget Johnson Dave has been absolutely wonderful to deal with. He is VERY receptive to emails and phone calls and is very quick in his responses and call backs. He has always gone above and beyond to help me with all my concerns and has always been very helpful! He takes care of everything for you and there is never any confusion. I would recommend anyone to switch over! You will not be disappointed. I will never go anywhere else!

Russell Sheldon You have to have insurance somewhere.

Penny Saunders Excellent insurance company.

Rachael Scharett Alexandra is the best agent to work with. I will continue to get all of my policies through her. She takes the times to understand your real needs and get the right policy coverage for you. 10/10 recommend!

Hakeem Adamu They helped me out with getting my car insurance situated. Everything was explained to me in a clear and concise manner. I would recommend

david vargas Very professional and on point with everything you need to know, flo is the person i been dealing with and she is very patient with all my questions and quick with responding to voice mail and emails thank you island insurance for a great experience

Kevin Mullen I have been doing business with Keep Insurance for the past 25 years for business and personal insurance and would highly recommend them to anyone. Joe Cantarella has always been there to give the proper information and guidance. The staff is also exceptional as well . E-mails and phone calls are returned quickly and customer service is exceptional . Anytime our rates go up they have the ability to shop out your policies and get quotes from many different companies . Cathy McCarthy recently took the time and effort to save me approximately $700.00 yearly on my auto policy . I also deal with Jenna on the company business policies and she always takes the time and makes the effort to make sure we are taken care of properly .Thank you to Joe and his staff .

Steven Cole Needed non-trucking liability while my truck was leased but off-duty some weeks. These folks helped structure it so I wouldn’t overpay. Also helped switch cargo coverage when my contracts shifted from electronics to general freight.

Karla sancalt I was comparing plans and this agency helped me bundle them efficiently. They took the time to understand my situation and really worked in my best interest.

Genesis Romero Thank you to Nadine for her kindness and willingness to help!