Robert Forest Fine Jewelers - Staten Island (NY)

Barbara Olsen Elizabeth is an absolutely terrific jeweler who does beautiful work. She has repaired several pieces for me, has restrung a pearl necklace and a jade bracelet, replaced a missing side stone in an emerald ring, and has cleaned many older pieces. All her work is beautifully executed and fairly priced. She is deeply trustworthy and knowledgeable and wonderful to work with. I highly, highly recommend!

Catherine Aspling Zales has been great in every way. Products, prices, and service. They are always prompt and considerate.

Jamie Loren Igor was a pleasure to work with! He’s knowledgeable and wants to make sure you walk away happy. We had a great experience buying our wedding rings and highly recommend!!

keith odell I purchased my wifes engagement ring from Doerrer jewelers 10 years ago and received excellent service back then. We recently purchased a 3ct amora diamond for my wife and had some very crappy service when trying to get it set from other jewlers. So..... we decided to pack the kids up and visit Donna. She was friendly, offered us multiple options, and spent a solid hour with us. I STRONGLY suggest shopping here. A++!!!!!!!

Raven Malfetano Papas Gold City is family! I’ve had the pleasure of working with Papas for almost 10 years! Their service is 10/10! If you want it they have it, and if they don’t have it- they can make it! Chris, Michelle, Zo, Christina, and the whole gang are true professionals. I will be getting jewelry from them for years to come!

Jasmin z The one-on-one customer service is unbeatable. I always know Im getting a good deal when I go to Lucky. I tried going to other jewelry shops in the area and Lucky always offers me better prices than their neighbors. For sure will be coming back here!

Angela Campbell This place is amazing. They have some unusual pieces, and I had the pleasure of meeting Harry and Stephanie. They are great people. Harry gives great prices, goes above and beyond for his customers, and has top-tier customer service. ❤️

Donna Young This is the only local jeweler in the Kenmore area. Hofert and Craig’s are now long gone so I wanted to continue to support local. I don’t have a long wait. I brought in jewelry to have an estimate on its worth. I was able to sell my jewelry at cost and it was easy and quick. I found everything to be efficient and friendly.

Ellen Cohen Holsten Jewelers is wonderful in so many ways. They are professional, extremely knowledgeable and very warm. The jewelry is beautiful and well priced. I completely trust them. It is always a treat going there, whether I am purchasing a piece of jewelry or just getting a new battery for my watch. Best jewelry store around!!

Caroline Merryman Montague helped me re-set this family emerald into a more art deco ring as a gift for my mom. Turnaround was pretty quick and prices super reasonable. Very happy with how it turned out!