KAY Jewelers - Olean (NY)

Diana L I needed to sell an old diamond and not only did John gave me a great price but he also found me a gorgeous replacement at a fantastic deal. John is very knowledgeable when it comes to diamonds and gems and I would definitely recommend him if youre in the market to sell or buy.

Rosa Maria Castillo Kesper I would say that Adam’s is the Cheers of jewelers where “they’re always glad you came and they always know your name.” Whether you are a high roller buying a Rolex, or an Anniversary, Birthday, engagement or special event gift, you are treated with respect and your needs and resources, whether expansive or limited are also respected. Most importantly is the assurance of their honesty and the inspired trust that is their trademark is merited. I could cite the names of specific staff and their respective impeccable service but consider these comments applicable to all.

Michael Kinner Hands down the best jeweler experience in the Southern Tier! Adam and his team has always been extremely helpful with any of my jewelry needs and requests. The entire staff is well educated on their product and their service is par none. Not to mention it is nice to support a local family owned business; especially one where the owner is vested with certified schooling and an education to back his knowledge. From sales, service and fabrication Comfort & Sons Jewelers has been my choice for over 20 years with no end in sight.

Stephanie Agurkis Love this place! Very well curated, and nothing is too precious. Items are priced fairly. Lots of styles and sizes. Cant wait to go back!

Kayla Silva Lena Gianna jewelry is absolutely amazing! Lena curates beautiful handmade pieces for all consumers! I have had the pleasure of visiting her pop up in Miami and had an amazing experience. Her customer service is truly exceptional, she worked with me to create a custom piece and I have yet to take my necklace sets off! Support my girl & Shop small businesses!!

Geri Smith Very satisfied does a beautiful job kind and courteous he knows his stuff

Kate Browning Schooley’s was awesome. I personally chose them over other jewelers after feeling like other stores treated shoppers with higher budgets with more attention and courtesy. Dave was incredibly nice and everyone else in the store was very welcoming. I had three pieces: 1) a loose mystery stone from my mother that I thought was glass 2) an old aquamarine ring that I inherited from my grandmother and 3) an engagement ring that was too big. The loose stone was actually an aquamarine and I had it made into a pendant. Dave was awesome throughout the entire process and I love the final product. I asked for the ring to be resized after contemplating having it reset — and even though it was less money for Schooley’s they respected my decision that the original setting was sentimental to me. The ring is amazing and so clean I hardly recognized it My engagement ring was resized in just a few days and is flawless as well. Overall 10/10 and 5 stars :)

Colin Bachert Absolutely fantastic experience working with the crew at Northeastern Fine Jewelry. Emily guided me and my girlfriend, Kaitlyn, through the process of purchasing our engagement ring and finding what we loved. Thanks again to the incredible team!!

Joanne Ottaviano This is a true “Mom and Pop” jewelry store. Now that phrase can be tricky if you had lousy parents, and might not sound appealing. But trust me, these two are the kind of parents you’d actually want running your life. They do everything in-house from repairs, sales, and being warm and friendly. Before they took over, the original “Pop” was at the bench, so you’re basically getting decades of jewelry wisdom handed down like a family recipe. They’re personable, honest, and so trustworthy that if they suddenly decided to open a mechanic shop, I’d hand them the keys to my vintage car without a second thought. They’ve got it all from new jewelry, antique gems, watches, you name it. And they’ll do it all from fixing it, polishing it, or making it sparkle like new. They’ll also buy your Grandma’s gaudy gold bracelet if you’re tired of keeping it in a shoe box under your bed along with the spider webs. Cash it in and have some play money. I used to be loyal to a jewelry store in Closter, NJ, but I took a daring cross-border adventure (don’t worry, no politics here), to Nanuet, NY, and discovered this little “gem”(no pun intended). Best decision ever.

Laurie I have dealt with John for decades. Always pleased with both purchases and repairs. He has an excellent eye for design. Will be going there again when they open on Tuesday.