Matzenbacher Insurance Agency - New Athens (IL)

Brandi Telkamp Tony is exceptional! I couldn’t believe how quickly he provided me with a rate and was able to get my policy set up with a very affordable premium.

Barbara Parr Julie was amazing! So professional, knowledgeable and helpful. She was so easy to talk to and patient. She should give classes in CUSTOMER SERVICE . I was able to lower my auto and home bundle., I am excited about this experience. Thank you, Julie !

Kristen Leadbetter Steve and his office staff (Nicole) are incredibly responsive and thorough with whatever we need. They made navigating the claim on our home painless, and Nicole was a lifesaver when our mortgage company didn’t get our premium paid on time. I’ve been with American Family for 26 years because of this type of customer service.

Sofia Esmeralda Gallardo Marreros I like how transparent this company is. Affordable pricing, great coverage and no surprise fees. My car is in good hands and I finally feel secure.

Rhonda Biller I highly recommend Paul and Katie for all your Insurance needs. They exceeded our expectations and we now have better insurance for less money.

Erika Polite, helpful & quick.

DJ Keith Hughes Joel is honest hard working and gets it done. See Joel for all your insurance needs

Jessica parker ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I recently switched my insurance and had the pleasure of working with Sarah. She was extremely helpful, knowledgeable, and made the process smooth and stress-free. She found me great coverage and even helped me get some awesome discounts! Highly recommend her if you’re looking for someone who truly cares and goes the extra mile. Thanks again, Sarah!

Nikki Toler I have been insured through Eagle Insurance for 3 years and it has been a pleasure being a customer of theirs. Everyone that Ive had the pleasure of speaking with on the phone has always been very kind, courteous and polite. They always kept me informed and up to date with my renewals and were very helpful when I had to update my coverage or change vehicles on my policy. It has been wonderful having them as my insurance agent and they are definitely going to be missed now that I am no longer in the Illinois area.