Blue Nile - Orlando (FL)

Taylor Cayll From promise ring, to custom engagement ring and wedding band, amongst other things Yuliya is to this day our favorite! So helpful & so kind! Love seeing her every time I come in for my cleanings ❤️

Jasmine Gutierrez Diego is very attentive, pays attention to detail, and has a very high quality product. He is a skilled handcrafted jeweler and you will not be disappointed in his product. Highly recommend!

Sf Morris Robert Young worked with me to create a stunning necklace blending a small coin from my fathers collection with diamonds and rubies from my mothers rings. I now have a stunning modern piece that has great sentimental value. He is wonderful and really listens to what you would like and adds his own fabulously creative design touches. I could not recommend him more highly!

Craig Barber I had 5 rings made for a Marine Corps reunion, mine came in just a bit too tight. I found this store by accident, and have to say the staff, and the jeweler, are top notch. They took the time to get a proper size, and assured me it could be done quickly. I asked if it could be done faster than that, bottom line- they had my ring for less than 12 hrs and 8 of those were because the store was closed…. The ring fits perfectly, and they will take care of my brothers just as fast should their rings not fit right either. Thank You Stars Jewelers, and Jamal for the immediate work.

Jasmanny Medina Such a wonderful atmosphere extremely satisfied customer, honest people are hard to come by these days! I really loved all the peaces they repaired and sold me and best of all at a reasonable price. I am very grateful to have found this lovely family owned business and I look forward to many more purchases at the location. 5 stars ⭐️ extremely satisfied customer.

Kathleen Watson After buying a few diamond pieces at auction, I began a search for a local gemologist who could confirm the jewelry was what it claimed to be. I chose John Shulla based on his business reviews, and I’m so glad I did. He is professional, personable, and very good at what he does. Everything he told me regarding my jewelry was right in line with what the seller said. He, also, gave me some excellent recommendations when I mentioned wanting to have some pieces reset, and he thoroughly explained the pro and cons of the people he was recommending & the process of what I wanted done. I highly recommend Mr. Shulla for all of your appraisal needs.

Barbara H. I was exploring Port St. Joes business district and wandered into this jewelry store. What a gem of a place with an amazing display and inventory of new and antique jewelry. Also i found the owner to be very helpful and a wealth of information. The best part was that i didnt feel out of place. Ill use them when Im ready to find something unusual in a store where I know Im welcomed! B

Carson Vazquez I had the absolute pleasure of having Erica T. help me with an engagement ring purchase back in April 2025. She was extremely kind, helpful, and friendly. I spent a good amount of time comparing different stones, bands, designs, etc., and Erica was patient through it all. I opted for a custom ring per her suggestion to take the single center stone from one ring and put it as the center stone in another band that contained side stones. The ring was ready for pickup less than two weeks later and it turned out beautifully. Fast forward to June, I planned out the proposal. I took my now fiancé up to one of our favorite spots while we were on vacation, the Blue Ridge Parkway. While we were stopped enjoying one of the many views, I got down on one knee with the mountains surrounding us and popped the question, it was perfect. She said yes and was completely in love with her ring. I appreciate everything Erica did for me to have a proper ring to propose with. I recommend any and all to KAY jewelers, as I was very pleased with the entire experience. I promised I’d leave a review for you Erica, so although a few months late, I didn’t forget :). Thanks again!

Henry Mosquera Thank you, Mr. Cortes, for creating the most amazing engagement ring for my bride-to-be! She is absolutely thrilled with her new ring. I highly recommend Mr. Cortes to anyone shopping for the perfect piece. He guided me through the entire process, from selecting the diamond to finalizing the design. Whether you prefer lab-grown or natural diamonds, both IGI-certified and appraised, he provides excellent options tailored to your needs and preferences. Thank me later (: