The Caldwell Agency Inc. - Canastota (NY)

Y Sarah (CurvaceousFairyPrincess) Very friendly service with knowledgeable staff. Loved the drive over through the beautiful countryside.

david vargas Very professional and on point with everything you need to know, flo is the person i been dealing with and she is very patient with all my questions and quick with responding to voice mail and emails thank you island insurance for a great experience

Sophia Russell Obligatory Insurance LLC has exceeded my expectations. Their team is professional, responsive, and always willing to help. They took the time to understand my needs and provided a tailored policy that offers great coverage. Their ongoing support and proactive communication have made managing my insurance needs effortless.

Hunter Stevens I’ve worked with a few different insurance agents and can safely say the degree of professionalism, thoroughness and dedication that Mike and his team at Aebly provide before AND after your policy is finalized is unmatched. He also got me the best rates of the agents I was working with. Highly recommend.

Kim Frost Your agency is great! Always friendly and helpful with any questions or changes we need made to our policies. We can always count on quick responses and actions. Your staff are very knowledgeable. Anything we need is just a quick phone call away, which is much appreciated!

Ken Hamilton Christine Westfall knows how to effectively run this business. She knows what she is talking about when it comes to multiple kinds of insurance. If she is uncertain, shell tell you and request to follow up. There is no bs between you and this insurance agent. She is always there to be one step ahead of you. She worked with us from start to finish on our insurance needs and never rushed us in and out. This was a month,long process -if that doesnt speak volumes of the business she does, then I dont know what would. Give the agency a try. Either way, you wont be displeased.

William Gilmore My senior father-in-law was in a tough situation financially and had his insurance canceled and did not know how to deal with it on his own, nor did he let us know what had happened to his coverage as far as being canceled. I would just like to specifically point out Caroline and Heather at the West 1st Street office in Oswego for their empathy and understanding of the unique situation. They were able to get him reinstated and able to put him at ease. Thank you ladies you guys are the best

Lisa Phelan Outstanding Service and Dedication! I recently needed to add a golf cart to my insurance policy, and what seemed like a simple request quickly turned into a complex process due to the vehicles non-traditional classification. Thankfully, I had the incredible support of Kathy Pratt at the Grimsley Agency! She spent over an hour patiently working through the challenges— keeping me informed every step of the way. Her persistence, professionalism, and willingness to go above and beyond made all the difference. If you’re looking for an agent who genuinely cares and will advocate for you, look no further!