Mayfair Jewelers - Scotia (NY)

Kelsey Tillman I can’t say enough good things about Alexis Russell Jewelry! The quality of their pieces is absolutely stunning — you can tell every detail is thoughtfully crafted. What really sets them apart, though, is their incredible customer service. A special shoutout to Gaby, who went above and beyond to help me with questions about resizing. She followed up every step of the way and made the entire process feel so personal and stress-free. I’m beyond happy with my experience and will definitely be a returning customer!

tashkia wadud I went in with my family and had a great experience. John was welcoming and extremely knowledgeable. He took the time to explain everything clearly and was very fair with his offers. You can tell he genuinely cares about what he does and treats people with respect. Definitely recommend checking this place out if you have items to sell or just need an expert opinion. Thanks again, John!

Jim NYC Very pleasant and helpful staff. Had an antique ring resized. They were able to do it while I waited and the price was very reasonable.

DJ A hidden gem in Ithaca. The reason I said its hidden is because the store is inside a building plaza. The store is not big but you can still find so many goodies. Just like the name, everything reminds you the past and will bring you back in time. You can find old jewelry, clothing, postcards, books, hats, toys and many more!

Jenny Ingrao I have been going to Mongillo Jewelers since 2010 for my trophies and plaques. They do an excellent job and have great quality products! Their customer service and quick turn around is why I keep coming back, even though I moved out of the area. They know what I am looking for and always have recommendations if Im not sure what I should order.

Allan Kerner Albert is the best. Super quality, unique items, fair pricing, informed service, easy parking, repairs, very competent guidance during the purchase process. You will be satisfied! My review based on years of shopping at his fine store.

Country Tile LLC I was being helped by Keri to look for a ring for my mom and she did an amazing job. She was absolutely helpful and provided many options. Thanks again Keri

Laura Mclaughlin I Love Royal Jewelers! I wouldn’t go anywhere else for my jewelry!! They know how to treat me every single time I come in and that’s what’s up. I love what I got and I’m forever grateful to Adil and Roby. Thanks guys!

Nadine Ive known Joe and Ina for many years, from when they were in Forest Ave, flea market! They both will go out of their way to make you feel welcomed. They truly have a unique shop, lots of vintage jewelry, I think thats what drew me to them in the first place, nothing is same ole same ole. I was so happy to see theyre still in business on New Dorp Lane, since Ive been off the island for over 8 years. I travelled to them from upstate NY to get my granddaughter a piece of jewelery for her 18th birthday and graduation. As soon as I walked in Ina remembered me, we had some nice conversation and a pleasant shopping experience! As always they are 2 very fine people along with their son Gary, and Im so happy we were able to do business! Thank you so much, I will only buy from your shop. Happy to see you both, Nadine

Jai Das After researching jewelers from Central Park to the Financial District, and even some out of the state, none matched the skill and warmth we found at Magnolia Jewelry. Dolly was phenomenal, she guided me and my fiancé through every step of the process. We brought in my fiancée’s grandmother’s diamond ring, hoping to rework it into something uniquely hers. Magnolia brought our vision to life, sharing detailed CAD designs before crafting a flawless final piece that exceeded our expectations. Their in-house team completed everything in under a month, and the pricing was more than fair for such exceptional craftsmanship. Highly recommend Magnolia for any jewelry needs.