Dorothys Fine Jewelry - Sayville (NY)

Nicole Marinaro I didn’t have any part of designing my beautiful ring but they obviously knocked this out of the park. I’ve gone in to have it resized and I cannot emphasize enough how amazing and nice they are and how amazing they did with this ring!

Jonathan Alvarado Best around great deals

faustina hines We are writing to extend our immense gratitude and appreciation of the excellent customer service received from your employee Mimi. It is not every day that one comes across a service as warm, pleasant, proficient and swift as the one we received. Mimi addressed our concerns with the utmost priority and attention to detail. We are very impressed by her professionalism and service. Please accept our heartfelt gratitude and sincere thanks for a job well done. You can be assured we will be steadfast clients for many years to come and we will recommend your establishment to friends and family. Warm regards, Alfonso & Tina Hines

Aneu Twenty I had jewelry that I was not using anymore and trusted it to Eduardo and his very capable Coworkers. I wish I had a picture of what I gave him to fully appreciate the masterpiece he created. Looking forward to my second project.

Bianca Walker I’ve purchased all my jewelry from him, always kind and professional.

Brittany C Dropped my wedding bands off to be resized to one size bigger. I picked my rings up the next day and theyre perfect. Cant see any marks from the sizing and no stones fell out. Pricing was not bad at all either.

Angela A. Just visited Kay jewelers in newburgh. I had the most pleasant experience. Marie was so helpful and patient. She took her time to help me select the perfect ring. I will definitely to shopping there again real soon. Thank u ladies!

Ratna Payel80 What a wonderful vibe this jewelry store has. As an islander I always try to give money to my local business before go to the big ones. And I am so glad I end up coming here. Customer service is always excellent, a lot of time my experience in the island with local businesses isn’t good, so this was breath of fresh air. Every time I step into this place the respect they showed me is commendable. Now let’s talk about what I ended up getting. As a Muslim a groom cant wear gold or silver wedding rings, so I had to find a stainless steel one for the groom . They also did custom engraving & it looked beautiful. I will try to post pictures later . Thank you so much all the hard work you guys do , we all appreciate your efforts.

esther weiss I’m flawed by the service I got when I walked in Sunday. I needed a day to think of the ring cause the amount of stunning stuff they have Bonnie the sales lady offered me her personal cell # for when I do decide The next day I reached out to her after work hours And got my ring purchased while the store was already closed and had it ready to be taken the next day to get sized I’m in shock how 2 days later I get it by my door sized to my size Wow wow wow the service is unreal Bonnie is the best!!!! (I’m sure the other sales ppl are just as good ) (Pic don’t do justice )