Fortune Jewelers - Staten Island (NY)

5 /5 Nadine: Ive known Joe and Ina for many years, from when they were in Forest Ave, flea market! They both will go out of their way to make you feel welcomed. They truly have a unique shop, lots of vintage jewelry, I think thats what drew me to them in the first place, nothing is same ole same ole. I was so happy to see theyre still in business on New Dorp Lane, since Ive been off the island for over 8 years. I travelled to them from upstate NY to get my granddaughter a piece of jewelery for her 18th birthday and graduation. As soon as I walked in Ina remembered me, we had some nice conversation and a pleasant shopping experience! As always they are 2 very fine people along with their son Gary, and Im so happy we were able to do business! Thank you so much, I will only buy from your shop. Happy to see you both, Nadine

5 /5 Emily Isakson: I called about a ring I saw online, and got a very fast response about it. Fortune Jewelers went out of their way to answer my questions and to create an appropriately priced invoice! The ring came to me within one business day of being shipped, and came beautifully wrapped and polished. Great service and beautiful, quality jewelry!

5 /5 Stephen A: Old fashioned jewelry stored run by a husband and wife. I went there to have a few pieces of jewelry repaired. One things they had a great selection of was single hoop earrings for men. I love what I picked out.

5 /5 Michael Walsh: Purchased a gorgeous vintage ring as a gift for my wife and Fortune (Gary in particular) couldnt have been more pleasant to buy from. Not only was the listed price of the ring fair, Gary was kind enough to include sales tax, shipping, AND sizing in the final price, making it something of a bargain. And on a ring my wife had already seen and was adamant I should do everything in my power to get for her - Gary could have easily had me over a barrel on the price, but instead chose to be the better man and give me a deal! And who doesnt want to save a few bucks, right? As to the size of the ring, I knew it would be too small and needed to go up a couple of sizes. Now I was a bit freaked out about this because I wanted to be certain it went right the first time, and I spent literally days with my wifes existing collection and a caliper trying to make sure I got it right. After going back and forth a couple of times over whether to go 9 or 9.25 I eventually decided on 9. Gary even told me that I could ship the ring back for resizing if Id gotten it wrong (it turned out that I was bang on). Another concern is how "new" a 30-40 year old ring could look and, as it turned out, I neednt have worried - I dont know if this was carefully purchased by Fortune or if they restored it to perfection, but the ring is spectacular. You cant even tell where gold has been added for the resizing. Communication was stellar, sizing was quick, and shipping was 2nd day air via UPS. Overall, an extremely nice buying experience.