Castle Hill Jewelry - Bronx (NY)

Christina Broecker Mills is amazing. They created a custom engagement & wedding band for us. I’ve also had them repair older jewelry. Adding lost diamond chips & fixing prongs. They are reasonable & pay close attention to detail. I worked with Brian on my custom set. He was patient with my million ideas. End result is beautiful & we couldn’t be happier. We were even invited to watch the engagement ring be assembled in the store. Turn around, customer service and quality are fantastic. I recommend mills to anyone looking. Superior quality to chain jewelers. Don’t cut corners with something as important as your diamond(s).

Kobi Benlevi They were incredibly helpful in evaluating the value of various precious metal items. I wholeheartedly recommend them for any needs related to jewelry, timepieces, or other valuable possessions.

Tanisha Crichlow Thank you so much for Diamond Source and Igor creating the most magical engagement ring! I was beyond surprised and happy at how beautiful my ring was from my fiancé. Igor worked really well with my fiancé on the details and ensuring it fit his needs and mine! Please see Igor for all your jewelry needs!

Janet M D’Erricos is my favorite jewelry store by far. The most professional, reliable and friendliest staff who are truly knowledgeable and excellent at their craft. Design, repairs, settings, sizing and more are all done on premises with owners overseeing everything. Look no further!

Kat Tak The staff is always friendly and helpful, before and during social distancing. Its always nice to see the same sales associates every time I go. Theyre as quick to remember you as you them. The order and pickup service is very convenient too, especially this time of year. Ive shopped there for years and have never had a complaint.

James Durand My mother shopped here for many years and she always loved everything she purchased. I have been shopping here for my wife for over 18 years. Jim has always treated me well and has been very helpful with my every purchase. I always find the perfect gift! I love Romanation Jewelers See you soon!

Jacqueline Jaramillo I can’t say enough great things about the Zales store in Astoria! Every single time I visit, I’m met with exceptional customer service that goes above and beyond. The entire staff is consistently warm, attentive, and incredibly helpful—making each visit a truly enjoyable experience. What truly elevates this store is the store manager, who is an absolute pleasure to interact with. Their professionalism, friendliness, and genuine care for customers shine through in every conversation. They lead by example, creating an atmosphere that feels welcoming and personal, and it’s clear that the team thrives under their guidance. Whether I’m browsing, getting a piece cleaned, or making a special purchase, the service is always top-tier. I leave every time feeling valued and appreciated. If youre looking for a jewelry store where you’ll be treated with kindness and respect, the Zales in Astoria is the place to go. A true 5-star experience from start to finish!

Bianca Lavi I’ve had several custom pieces made by Fernando, and every single one has exceeded my expectations. His craftsmanship is exceptional—each piece was perfectly executed with great attention to detail. Fernando is hardworking, reliable, and often completes projects ahead of schedule. Both he and his wife are a pleasure to work with—genuine, kind, and professional. The quality of the jewelry is outstanding. I highly recommend Fernando for anyone seeking high-quality, custom-made pieces.

Blaze Johnny “Chef” Amazing set of guys in here...YOU WILL NOT GET A BETTER DEAL...ANYWHERE... HONEST AND JUST A PLEASURE

Daniel Sciascia Scanlon Jewelers is a true gem in the Amherst, NY community. I’ve been a loyal customer for years, and their integrity, professionalism, and commitment to exceptional customer service are unmatched. Whether it’s engagement rings, men’s and women’s jewelry, watches, or expert repairs—Scanlon has it all. Brady Scanlon and Danny Duguay have always treated me with the utmost respect and care, making every experience personal and seamless. Their knowledge, honesty, and dedication set them apart. For anyone looking for a trusted jeweler, Scanlon Jewelers has my highest recommendation. Great work!!