Tingley Insurance Agency - Effingham (IL)

John Scheibal, Sr. Joe gave good information on my current policies and also gave some good advise that would fill in some gaps in my current coverage.

Robert Cramer I had a fantastic experience with Pro First Insurance Service. Their team is knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely invested in their clients satisfaction. They provided a thorough assessment of my needs and found a policy that fits perfectly. Their ongoing support and accessibility make them a standout choice in the insurance industry.

Richard Kinkade Great family and Christian people, honestly looking to help drivers out with insurance for them and their families

Richard Hutchison Hands down, the best insurance agent Ive ever had.

Scott Gordon We have been with Allstate for 40 years. They have always handled our claims quickly and easily. We especially love that they are partnered with Safelite for auto glass. It makes the claim process to replace a windshield so easy!

Peggy Thomas Jim is great! He takes good care of his clients. Ive been with Country for 32 years!

Naydeline Itzel Loria Aguilar I’ve been with this agency for a while now and I’ve always been impressed with their service. The agents are very responsive and I can always count on them to provide accurate answers to my questions.