Tingley Insurance Agency - Effingham (IL)

Charles McKenna By far the best experience I’ve had with any insurance company. Everyone here is so helpful and knowledgeable! Emily takes care of business!

mx girl18 Dani was so great at giving me a quote. She was on top of it and did it in a timely matter! We appreciated her hard and detail work.

Airamanda Kordalewski Jefton has been taking care of my business and my family’s personal needs for several years now. He is professional, timely, and very responsive (even when I tell him something can wait!). I have been with State Farm for 22 years now and he is BY FAR the best agent I have worked with. Happy to have someone like him on my side.

Squig822 Jennifer is a delight to work with. Having tried online insurance companies in the past, it is so great to work with a local agent again. She answered all our questions and assisted in creating the coverage we need for home and autos. Highly recommended!

Kmdly.1 The team helped me customize my coverage based on my car needs. They explained every detail clearly and made sure I was comfortable with the plan. Great experience

Sally Ann Tirey It was great working with Austin. I believe he went over and above to help me get the best policy available for my needs without an outrageous premium. I would recommend Austin for all your insurance needs. Thanks again Austin

5XL ATV My father started using Gary Welch many years ago and when he passed away I kept him/them as my office and agents. I have never had any issues and the personal feel makes it even more worth it.

Elijah BranchJR My experience with rob everytime is very pleasant I could talk with him all day am wouldnt be worried hes a great person and very professional we need more people like him

Joshua Craven The team at New Horizons is absolutely the best. As an independent insurance agent, Id be lost without their support. Thanks!

Josh Jackson This office is one of the best I have witnessed! There was a kind , considerate , caring person working that day . Her name was Alicia, she was very professional and informative, she found ways to save me lots of money and keep almost the same coverage! Thank you so much !