Olde City Jewelry & Pawn - St. Augustine (FL)

Mr A I’ve visited just about every major watch and jewelry retailer—from big names like Mayors to luxury boutiques like Bucherer—and I can confidently say Hamilton Jewelers stands in a league of its own. Across all of their locations—The Gardens, Worth Avenue, and Princeton—the level of service, kindness, professionalism, and genuine care is world-class. This isn’t just a store—it’s a family. And you feel that the moment you walk in. At the Gardens location, I’ve been consistently blown away by Ted, Richard, Jacqueline, and Nicholas. Their knowledge is top-tier, but more than that, they’re warm, thoughtful, and never pushy. Just genuinely great people. At Worth Avenue, Stephen and Beth exemplify what it means to offer a luxury experience without the ego. They treat you with real respect, no matter if you’re browsing or buying. And in Princeton, Terri and Michael carry the same energy—graceful, welcoming, and passionate about what they do. Hamilton is family-owned, and it shows. Hank and his family have built something truly special—a place that blends the best of luxury with the best of humanity. The inventory is fantastic, from exquisite in-house jewelry to rare and diverse watch brands that would impress any serious collector. I’ve purchased multiple pieces for my wife—watches and jewelry—gifts for my daughters, and added several watches to my own collection. Every visit is a pleasure, not because of what I leave with, but because of who I get to interact with. Over time, they’ve become more than trusted advisors—they’ve become friends. If you’re looking for a place where expertise meets integrity, and where luxury feels personal, Hamilton is it.

Leah Kohnert I came to this pawn shop last week for the first time , Mike gave me a quote on a piece of jewelry .. I came back The following week, he honored the exact same price he quoted to me… He was extremely professional, friendly, honest trustworthy … enjoyed doing business with him and will def recommend this pawn shop to my friends and family . Thanks Mike!!

Donna Trovarello Luis was extremely helpful and very friendly. We went in to get a jewelry repair, and they did it on the spot and it was really reasonably priced. The jewelry was beautiful and unique. I will be going back so they can design me a custom ring.

Carol Purvis Very personable and professional service! Highly recommend! Paul was very kind and patient with my elderly mother who needed adjustments to her jewelery so it would be easier for her to take necklaces on and off by herself. He gave her several options and helped her find just the right thing. We will be repeat customers for sure! Service like this is really hard to find and we appreciate the work they put in!

Larissa This is a well established trustworthy jeweler store and jewelry repair ran by a fine family. They fixed my jewelry right. I like their honesty, dependable quality of work and fair prices.

Beto Yanes Sherrie Alpert is amazing! She always takes care of me when I come. I’ve been getting my watch batteries changed here and my watch links adjusted here for some time now and they are the best! Quick, reliable, and reasonable pricing! They also have gorgeous pieces. I definitely recommend.

The Godmother And her hitmen I love this boutique so much! Her gallery of beautiful things to look at surrounding the amazing options for sale can be a little overwhelming for some people and they want to touch. I was in the other day and a couple was so rude about her clearly posted signs. Show respect and get respect. She is a kind and generous woman with a big heart but sets clear boundaries. Also, while Im here “that’s so expensive” is an inside thought. Her prices are fair and you’re not at a thrift store ;). Support small business in a respectful way.

Michael McCauley I took my TAG Heuer watch in because it had condensation inside of it. They fixed it up brand new and super quick plus the price was unbelievably low. They make all their jewelry there in the store and have some amazing pieces. I’ll be back for future jewelry repairs and hopefully purchases soon!

Fresh 1hunna Best jewelry store in Florida Hands Down!!! So if u looking for any type of jewelry I will highly recommend you going to B&M jewelry.They treat everyone like family & listen to customers concerns.Mike made my custom diamond & White gold pinky Ring just like i wanted it .Mike & His son Jacob are the best in the game.

Lauren Bentzel The girl working there was very nice! She was very helpful in helping me pick out a beautiful jade bangle. The other jewellery there was also beautiful, and I would definitely shop there again :)