Robert L Shumway Jr. - Plattsburgh (NY)

5 /5 Amy Smith: Todd was amazing! Worked with me to get the best price and was quick getting me in and out with paperwork on my lunch! Definitely would recommend them to family and Friends. Progressive had me at 148 and I was able to get policy at 120 with rental insurance for my apartment and rental car that I didnt have threw progressive!

5 /5 Beverly Swaylik: Of all the insurance companies I have dealt with I will be a customer of shumways and Erie insurance for a long time

1 /5 Matthew Furman: Id like to warn people about this agency. They have great customer service while you are a customer. However when you cancel a policy with them they become hostile and rude. And refuse to perform simple business requests such as faxing a copy of your policy documents. The owner Robert Shumway is especially bad in the way he treats departing customers. I did not have any issues prior to this and other than feeling my policy was too expensive I was overall satisfied with this agency until I decided to leave (a competitor found a much lower rate). If you are shopping around for an insurance policy, there are other agencies in town which will treat you much better. I urge you to check the yellow pages and do your homework.

5 /5 Kimberly Fountain: The ladies here make your day brighter with their constant smiles and such positive attitudes. They will do everything they can to get you the best insurance possible.

5 /5 Jennifer Garrow: The people that work here are very friendly and they all have a great sense of humor. They help you with whatever you need and always let you know your best options. I would recommend this place to anyone. They always get things done in a timely manner.