Diamond Insurance - Warsaw (NY)

Pauline Liu I had a wonderful experience getting my boat insured with Toedt Insurance. Some friends suggested I look into local brokers because I could get better rates and more hospitality. That was absolutely true! Sherry Toedt took my call and signed me up. She was remarkably patient, professional and helpful. I wasn’t sure what to expect because I called at the end of the day. I thought she might ask me to call back in the morning. Instead, she went right to work processing my coverage. It was a relief to have the coverage. I did notice that Toedt Insurance has many 5-star reviews. Now, I know why.

sevda mirzayeva Thank you for the service! Great staff, professional service and helped me to save a lot of money for car insurance. Highly reccimended.

Cary Shi I had a great experience working with Nikki! She was extremely detailed throughout the entire process and made sure I fully understood everything. She answered all of my questions clearly and patiently, which I really appreciated. Thanks to her help, I was also able to save money on my insurance. I highly recommend Nikki—she’s knowledgeable, responsive, and truly looks out for her clients!

Mitch Lurie This review has been a long time coming. Mark Anderson has been nothing but helpful, supportive and honest about everything since my wife and I bought our home last year and decided to go to State Farm for home owners insurance. Not to mention the amount he happened to help us save on an auto policy at the same time. Thank you for all you’ve done for us!

Allison Tanzer Super helpful agency. They were so understanding and knowledgeable of all the different ways to insure my family. Thank you!

Samantha Burris I cant even begin to describe the amount of gratitude we have for this office, in particular, Stacy Gleason. We were in such a bind with our auto insurance and was able to get coverage quick and easy over the phone, that beat all the other auto insurers cost. Highly recommend!

Samantha Frank We had a tornado rip through our town on June 22nd. Jess and the rest of the staff at the rizzo agency have been absolutely amazing, super helpful, and caring throughout this whole process. We couldnt ask for a better company to have our insurance through!

Lee Teitsworth Currently there are three reviews of this agency, with an average rating of 2.3 stars. Im not sure Ive written a review on Google, but that number is so absurd, I feel compelled to weigh in. Initially (several years ago) I asked for an insurance quote for for my truck because of a family members referral who had had a positive experience. Not only did I switch to State Farm through this agency for my truck, but also I added my wifes van and switched our homeowners policy to receive the multi-line discount. After a careful reading of the policies compared, we now enjoy superior coverage *and* saved close to $700/year. As with any insurance rates can change, so review frequently; but the kicker, in complete contrast with some other reviewers, repeatedly I have found their level of service to be exceedingly high. Because of that, it would take more than a minor savings to move me away from this agency.

Monica Caulfield I felt I was paying too much for my auto and renters policies at AllState and went to Liotta Insurance to see what he could do. He got me better coverage on both policies for a good deal less money. I am so glad I went to Liotta. I just wish I had gone sooner.

Cherie Cooper Diane Nies has worked with us over the last few years with our insurance needs. She has been wonderful! But when an issue for our daughter arose she was nothing but amazing even sitting in her car with no power working on a deal for us, that is truly above and beyond. If you need insurance call her!! Thank you Diane!!