KAY Jewelers - Shirley (NY)

jdozer25 Very friendly staff and helpful. Fixed my watch within 10 minutes and for a good price too. Also they do some program with veterans so hats off to yall.

David H Been doing business here going on 28 years. Now live out of state and had my wedding band repaired (25 +years) and looks brand new. Thank you for continuing amazing personalized service, they make you feel like a member of the family.

Dakota Jewell In love with my engagement ring that my fiance purchased through Mars Jewelry! Fits perfectly and looks gorgeous. My guy was super impressed by the customer service here and how quickly the ring was ready for pickup, as well. Pricing was more than fair too and Bill stayed in contact every step of the way. Definitely will be our new go-to place for all related needs. Thanks again!

unexpectedly The shop has been here a while.prices are fair, and the owners are nice and hard working. My family has always gotten great results with customizations too. Will return again!

Martin Rosen Sensitive reliable competent and reasonable

Amanda Iadevaio Great shop in town. Perfect for gifts or a gift for yourself. Lots of local goods and info. A must visit

D Nice WOW, just WOW! I have to give a HUGE shoutout to Michael and Kathy at Holston Jewelers! I was on a mission to find the perfect engagement ring, and let me tell you, I knew NOTHING about rings. I hit up several big-name jewelers, and they were all a total letdown. No one even tried to educate me or dive into the details of what I might want. But then, I walked into Holston Jewelers, a local gem, and met Michael and Kathy. These two are absolute rockstars! They took the time to teach me all about engagement rings, guiding me through every step with patience and expertise. They really got what I was looking for and helped me zero in on the perfect ring. It wasnt an easy journey, but Michael and Kathy made it an unforgettable experience. They were simply wonderful, and now, Ive got the ring of my dreams thanks to them! If youre looking for someone who genuinely cares about your big moments, head over to Holston Jewelers! You wont regret it!

Jessenia Caquias I stumbled upon this store by chance and I am so glad I decided to go inside. Benny and Alex were amazing, their pieces were stunning, and their prices were even better. They have earned a new customer for sure. I’ve already started raving about them to my jewelry lover community and my family. Attached is a photo of the gorgeous bezel ring I purchased during my first visit. Thank you guys and see you again soon!

Shelly Warner I stopped in the West Village location this weekend to make my first Gorjana purchase. I wanted a necklace for my birthday and a Miss Kate assisted me in finding the right necklace and length as I am very tall, etc. I found one that I absolutely love and she was very sweet and helpful. Highly recommend!