JCPenney - Staten Island (NY)

Knsp Phillip I was absolutely blown away by the customer service provided by Layla and Cassandra. They were extremely pleasant and helpful whilst making meaningful recommendations. They greeted me with warm smiles as soon as I entered. Having visited this location several times before, this was by far the best experience! Thank you Layla and Cassandra.

Stephanie DuRocher This beautiful small home town store is wonderful. Beautiful jewelry, honest, nice, professional staff. The jewelers are very talented. They have fixed many items of mine that my other jewelers could not. Reasonable prices. Masterful custom items. Hard to not find something special. Thank you.

Ahmed Mahbub Absolutely love their jewelry! I ordered a few pairs of earrings and they’re even more beautiful in person. The quality is great, prices are affordable, and the styles go with everything from casual to dressy. Shipping was quick too. Definitely recommend checking out their collection if you’re looking for something stylish and well made.

25Lilac Im very happy with my experiences at Mayfair Jewelers. The staff members are personable and knowledgeable. Recently I stopped in and Evan was happy to help me with a repair. It was a done quickly and professionally. Would recommend!

Christopher Marin Best experience I’ve ever had buying jewelry, hands down. Very friendly and comforting staff. No pressure on the buyer whatsoever which is what I dread the most when I go to places like this. Very warm and inviting atmosphere. Beautiful selection and reasonable prices. Will definitely be back. Thank you so much Naheed. You were amazing.

arubio47 I got my son’s ears pierced for his birthday. Esa was so great that I actually went back after we left and got another piercing for myself! She took her time with placement of the earrings and was just really sweet and comforting. The staff was great! Highly recommend!

Carter Hall Thank you so much Justin!! He helped me and my fiancé pick out the perfect wedding ring! A very kind and knowledgeable manager. He even complimented the rings I had on, which belonged to my fiancé’s grandmother. Justin knows style, and he really made us feel comfortable in our decision! Thanks again from Carter and Elbe

S Rodgers I couldn’t possibly rate the overall experience better. I felt welcomed the moment I entered the shop. The atmosphere is relaxing, and the staff were extremely friendly. Lynda was so patient and sweet while assisting me with jewelry selections. I was a little anxious (quietly) but Noah put me quickly at ease. He has a calm presence about him and the process was over before I even realized it began. I would highly recommend this business for being a step above.

Kathleen Fortunato Buffalo Bannon is an amazing company, and makes quality, long lasting custom pieces of jewelry. I love scrolling through the website, and if I find something that I want, its purchased and shipped within a timely manor! I inquired about some custom earrings and she responded right away, and made them that week even though I know she was so busy with the holiday season. My favorites are my Buffalo Bills earrings made of sterling silver. I have more of a simplistic style when it comes to earrings, and they are PERFECT for everyday wear. Thank you, Tess, for creating such beautiful and unique pieces. Your work ethic, customer service, and creativity SHINES in your business, and the love for what you do shows.