Eatons Plaza Jewelers - Penn Yan (NY)

Scott Frost Top Shelf is an absolute gem—a must-visit for vintage clothing, handmade jewelry, vinyl records, antiques, and everything in between. But what truly sets it apart is Barb, the incredible owner. She’s a treasure trove of stories and local knowledge, and her warmth and wit are just as memorable as the curated finds in the shop. Barb is one of a kind, and a visit to Top Shelf is guaranteed to leave you inspired and smiling.

Dave Wells Bill and his team are absolutely wonderful, very knowledgeable and helpful! The service, price and professionalism are worth the 1 hour drive from Rochester. Highly recommend buying there!

Ryan Dreher The staff were incredibly courteous and helpful. They adjusted my watch very quickly and at no charge. Its heartwarming to know that there are still businesses like this. Highly recommend.

Katie Santner What a gem of a store! This family-owned antique shop is truly a treasure trove, filled with a wide variety of unique items—from vintage collectibles to absolutely stunning fine and antique jewelry. Every piece seems to have a story, and the entire space feels warm, welcoming, and full of character. Katherine and Chris are incredibly knowledgeable—they’ve been collecting their whole lives, and Katherine’s passion for jewelry really shines through. She and Chris were so kind and helpful when I stopped in to find a special maid of honor gift for my sister. With their guidance, I found the sweetest, most meaningful vintage bracelet that I know she’ll treasure forever. And I cant forget to mention Rosebud, their sweet dog, who was the friendliest greeter! She made the whole experience even more special. You can tell how much heart and hard work has gone into building this store. After everything local businesses have faced since COVID, it feels especially important to support small, family-run stores like this one. Shopping here isnt just about finding something beautiful—its about being part of a community and supporting people who truly care about what they do. Can’t recommend it enough if you’re in the area! I’ll definitely be back anytime I’m visiting ADK!

Youna Lee Resized my engagement ring thats a family heirloom. He polished it and cleaned it up. I waited less than an hour for it to be done because he understood the sentimental value of the ring and my reason for not wanting to leave it. The ring looked brand new and he didnt charge me a ridiculous price. On top of his excellent work, he was also very professional, experienced, and very friendly. I am going back to get my bracelet redone as well. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Ivan Dario Outstanding, came for christmas gift for mom. Will return for sure! Highly Recommended!

Sam Brady B did an outstanding job helping me create my engagement ring for my fiancée. He was very responsive and friendly, and walked me through the entire process. He worked with me to modify the ring designs when I requested a few changes, and the final product was beautiful! I’ll be coming back for the wedding bands and would recommend him to anyone.

Judy Hosmer I had a wonderful experience at Let’s Bead! I went there with a string of red coral from my dear sister to restring into a necklace. Very sentimental piece. No idea how to accomplish Lydia helped me with supplies and offered a work area to complete and she was right there helping me with all questions. It was wonderful and I am so happy with my necklace. Thank you Lydia for everything.

anna baichu My experience with Hazel was great for a nose stud piercing. They gave tips on how to take care of the piercing and was accommodating.

Alex Chinea We had a wonderful experience working with Kathy and Zaltas Fine Jewelers on our custom enagememt ring! We live several hours away and Kathy made the experience easy, fun, and personal. She gave us a crash course in diamonds and helped us deisgn a beautiful ring. We HIGHLY recommend going to Zaltas Fine Jewlers. We cant wait to go back and design our wedding bands!