Shepherd Jewelry, Inc. - Sarasota (FL)

Paul Herber This jewelry store and the people who work here are absolutely amazing! I received so much help from JD with my purchases that I felt I really needed to give a shout out, and thank him (them) all being such a great business. No wonder it has been a successful business in Naples, FL for over 35 years. I strongly recommend this local store.

Honest Jew These people are some of the most unprofessional in the business. They wanted to charge me $1600 to repair a clasp on a watch that sells on eBay for $1600. They kept me on the hook trying to sell me a n extremely cheap quality leather band with a markup of hundreds as a backup plan for them. They are going to argue on the review that they didn’t, but here I am telling you about it. This went on for almost 2 months with zero effort to contact me back or follow up. Take your business anywhere else. The owner is too old to have every decision run by him. It’s comical how long things linger on, with that policy of 60 days and your jewelry is now ours. I got my stuff back by a week or so. How convenient

Carlos Perez Janay provided impeccable and friendly service during my visit to Aventura Jewelry. She was professional, patient, and made the entire experience smooth and enjoyable. Her attention to detail and warm personality truly made a difference. Highly recommend asking for Janay if you’re looking for top-notch service!

Steven hashemi I cannot recommend Joseph Taylor Jewelers enough! I had the pleasure of working directly with Joe, and from start to finish, the experience was seamless. I sent him a picture of exactly what I wanted, and he had the exact same thing custom-made—it turned out even more beautiful than I could have imagined! The craftsmanship is incredible, and my fiancé is beyond happy. Joe was amazing to work with—he always got back to me so quickly, answered every question, and made the entire process effortless. On top of that, the pricing was incredibly fair for such high-quality work. If you’re looking for a jeweler who truly delivers, this is the place. Thank you, Joe, for bringing our vision to life!

Alex Buckley Working with J.R. Dunn was fantastic. We’ve been looking for a one stop jeweler in South Florida that carries all the best lines and can do intricate custom work. Working with Jessica was so easy and we even got to meet the owner! They always treat you how you EXPECT to be treated - complementary snacks, coffee, sparkling water, and how could you miss the Veuve Clicquot. We got the custom engagement ring of our dreams along with an amazing watch - all in time for our big day. We’ve worked with other jewelers in Palm Beach and Boca, but we shall never work with anyone other than J.R. Dunn again. Can’t say enough about the personal touch. So important.

Toni Houser This is very good place to visit when it comes to knowing about crystals. The owner Vikki, knows the most out of everybody I know when it comes to crystals. Flea master flea market booth 62 blue isle! find her, she knows her stuff!!

Triston Quitugua They did an awesome job. Cory was super great and did a fantastic job on my necklace. Monahan jewelry in Atlantic beach told me they could not fix my necklace and told me it was not worth keeping. Fast fix in St Johns town center was also not able to fix it. I highly recommend Master Jewelry, they even gave me a 3 month warranty

Paulson Jim (Boise Realtor) Love this boutique jewelry store. Lots of very unique pieces many with ocean and sea life themes. Many have personal meaning and stories which the staff was anxious to share. I loved the pewter dragon flies, the nautilus designs, sand dollars, octopus, etc. Joy did a cameo shot with her sign. They do custom pieces too. Highly recommend stopping in.

Max Rosen I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Old Northeast Jewelers—truly one of the best jewelry stores I’ve ever visited. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and professionalism, making me feel like a valued customer rather than just another transaction. I brought in some gold to sell and was immediately impressed with how transparent and fair they were in assessing its value. They took the time to explain the process in detail, ensuring I understood how they calculated their offer. Unlike some places that lowball you, they gave me a very fair price for my gold, which I truly appreciated. While I was there, I also had the opportunity to browse their stunning selection of watches. I’ve always wanted a Rolex, and thanks to their expertise, I found the most incredible one. The watch was in pristine condition, and they gave me a fantastic deal on it. They didn’t rush me into making a decision, instead, they provided insightful information about different models, helping me choose the perfect one for my style and needs. What truly sets Old Northeast Jewelers apart is their customer service. The team was friendly, knowledgeable, and extremely helpful throughout the entire experience. They made sure I was completely satisfied with both my sale and my purchase. It’s rare to find a business that operates with such integrity and professionalism, and I can confidently say that they have earned a lifetime customer in me. If you’re looking for fair prices, top-tier jewelry and watches, and an exceptional shopping experience, I highly recommend Old Northeast Jewelers. Whether youre selling gold, looking for a luxury timepiece, or just browsing, you won’t be disappointed!