Mayors - Sarasota (FL)

5 /5 Joe Doherty: I recently purchased my Rolex from Mayors at UTC Sarasota, and I can honestly say it was one of the most pleasant and professional retail experiences I’ve ever had. From start to finish, the team made me feel genuinely valued — not just as a customer, but as a person. Melissa initially helped me begin the process and was incredibly knowledgeable, kind, and attentive. When I returned to finalize the purchase, John stepped in seamlessly. His professionalism and warmth made the entire experience feel effortless and enjoyable — he treated me with the kind of respect and sincerity that’s rare in retail today. I also had the pleasure of speaking with Anthony, their director, and the conversation we had was nothing short of awesome. His leadership clearly sets the tone for the team’s incredible customer service. You can tell this store runs on more than just sales — it runs on integrity, connection, and true appreciation for their clientele. Thank you again, Melissa, John, and Anthony, for making such a meaningful purchase feel even more special. You’ve got a customer — and a fan — for life.

5 /5 Elizabeth Santana: I had the absolute best experience with Mellisa! She took the time to really listen to what I wanted in a Rolex and made me feel so comfortable throughout the entire process. I never once felt rushed—she explained everything thoroughly and made sure I understood each step. Thanks to her patience, professionalism, and genuine care, she turned my dream into reality. I couldn’t be happier and highly recommend working with her.

4 /5 Bennett Fields: I have had it with people taking advantage of what they perceive to be nevaux riche. Mayor’s Anne Roger’s did not do me or Mayor’s justice in the purchase of my Rolex Submariner. Instead she charged me more than 50% on top of the market value for my watch. The entire shoppjng experience felt like I had been conned as it was the second time piece I had ever purchased and having purchased many others since then I am absolutely fed up with the memory of Mayors. I reached out to them to figure out a rebate or something they could do to satisfy the absolute highway robbery Anne Roger’s performed on my wallet when selling me my time piece. But I was a sucker she saw coming from a mile away and all I can say is that you need to do your research before involving yourself in the purchase of a Rolex. Now that I am down the road and a bit more knowledgeable I have no problems at all announcing to the world That I paid $16,442.12 for a watch that was used and is worth less than $7,600.00. Be forewarned when dealing with Mayors. You will pay through the nose UPDATE: THEY SENT ME THE BOX WITH THE WARRANTY CARD. JOHN can and will follow through on his promises. I recommend you deal with John if anyone. Only John.

5 /5 Brian Wacnik: Jonathon was excellent…professional, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. I had a lot on my plate that day, but he made the experience fast, smooth, and stress-free. I’m extremely happy with my purchase and appreciated how he handled everything. If you’re looking for someone who actually knows watches and treats you right, ask for Jonathon.