Catalli Insurance Brokers - San Mateo (CA)

5 /5 Rockford Valentino: It was a breeze dealing with Tony and he made the process easy. I reached out online and he got back to me in a timely manner and was able to lower my insurance cost while keeping the same coverage I perviously had.

5 /5 SloaneDog: Tony Catalli with Catalli Insurance Brokers of San Mateo is an outstanding insurance professional who delivers exceptional service and great pricing. Like many, we were searching for a reputable insurance company for auto/homeowners insurance, additionally, one with competitive and reasonable rates. We had an outstanding experience working with Tony Catalli from the initial phone call, follow up emails, right to the end, he made the process a smooth and stress-free one. What sets Tony Catalli apart from other brokers is his exceptional communication skills and knowledge of the insurance industry. His expertise and level of customer service is unique to this field and we could not be more satisfied. We found Tony Catalli to be very honest, genuine, and transparent. He went above and beyond to ensure we understood what we were purchasing, explaining the differences in coverage. He took time to listen and analyze our needs and match us with the right coverage. Tony was so prompt in returning messages, thoroughly answering our questions, and did not pressure us at all. We HIGHLY recommend Tony Catalli with Catalli Insurance Brokers, San Mateo to anyone looking for great insurance at a fair price with exceptional service.

5 /5 Jessica Flanigan: I cant say enough good things about Catalli Insurance Brokers and the exceptional service I received from Tony. After a frustrating experience elsewhere—where I was given no guidance and was simply told to "read the policy" myself—Tony was a breath of fresh air. From the moment we connected, he went above and beyond to ensure I understood every step of the process. His patience, expertise, and genuine commitment to helping me made all the difference. He didn’t just do the bare minimum—he made me feel like a valued client, not just another policyholder. If youre looking for an insurance broker who truly cares, I highly recommend Tony and Catalli Insurance Brokers.

5 /5 Cheryl Wayne: During the recent insurance industry havoc, I was among the cancelled policy holders, with no satisfactory answers or assistance from my current broker. Three weeks later, 4 brokers, and hours of application submissions, I was frustrated and panicked. Then I found Tony Catalli. He was immediately responsive and knowledgeable. Three days later, I had clear candid answers, more professional advice, and a seamless application process. I am more confident than ever that Catalli is a full support agency that I will wholeheartedly recommend to friends and family. Thank you Tony!

5 /5 Sean J: Tony and his team have been very helpful in finding better insurance options when my previous provider raised the premiums considerably even though I had never filed a claim. He and his team were always responsive and following through when I needed to make changes as well. Highly recommended!