1 /5 Sean Stevenson: I had a motorcycle policy with two motorcycles with the Nancy Leavitt Agency LLC. On August 6, 2024 I sent an email to the Leavitt Insurance team to cancel the insurance on one of my motorcycles. I received a confirmation email back from the Nancy Leavitt Agency stating that my KTM 690 Duke has been cancelled and that any refund will be mailed to the address on file. My yearly insurance policy renewal is on 3/28/25, so on Monday (3/17/25) I logged in to my online American Family Insurance portal to make sure the auto-renewal took place and to print my new insurance cards. To my dismay, there was no policy and every tab was blank. I immediately called the Nancy Leavitt Agency, which went to voicemail, so I sent two emails to the Nancy Leavitt Agency asking for someone to call me ASAP. A couple hours later I received a call from Nancy Leavitt. She confirmed that her agency didnt just remove the insurance on the one bike (KTM 690 Duke), but cancelled the whole policy. She then went directly in to trying to sell me more coverage and talking about covering "customizations". I was dumbfounded by her behavior! There was zero explanation, sympathy and/or apology for putting me in this immense situation of not having insurance for 7 months! Also, I never received a cancellation letter, a cancellation email, a cancellation text, a cancellation phone call, or a cancellation email from my policy portal. If I would have, I would have been able to purchase a new policy elsewhere and not be riding a motorcycle without insurance. I received two calls from a regional person aka…”retention representative” regarding this issue and his only goal was to try to get me back as a customer, even after I told him I already purchased a new policy with another company (3 times cheaper & more coverage) and I would never do business with AFI again. The gall this guy had was incredible! AFI has a “used car dealership” mentality. I highly recommend you look elsewhere for your insurance needs!
