Hidden Gem - Bainbridge Island (WA)

Douglas Musolf Thank You for the exceptional work on my wifes custom ring. The service was professional and one of a kind. Your professionalism surpassed any other privately owned local jeweler. The work was completed and expedited to meet our time frame. Thanks for all the work.

Katrina Johnson Wow, what an amazing experience. I am so grateful that we ended up going here because they really made it a special day for our daughter. I love the fact that they have the two piercers at once to make it go so smooth and easy. They were also really good about the aftercare protocols and they even followed up with us a couple weeks after to make sure that her healing was going well. thanks so much for making an experience for a child so memorable! And for me too! Happy mommy!

Dommy Dee Lemmie start with this was an overall, great experience. Ive sold things at other stores, and none come close to my experience here. Staff was very friendly & knowledgeable and gave me a fair price for my items. Will Definitely come back here next time, and would recommend them to anyone looking.

Shayna Hallman I was looking for a wedding band on a small budget and I found one that I absolutely LOVE. The staff was incredibly helpful and knowledgeable and they have an amazing selection of used and affordable natural diamond wedding bands. Couldn’t have been more thankful to have found Diamond Banque!

madi green The boutique is beautiful and Kyah is a doll! Talked me through the process and explained how long the jewelry is supposed to last! My bracelet is gorgeous!

Erin Dawson Excellent service and quality. I enjoy the employees. They are so helpful and have great ideas for gifts. If you are looking for a locally owned jeweler, look no further. Shop local!

alHalwima This has the equivalent of an entire gem fairs worth of gemstones, minerals, and fossils and is the largest store of its kind for many miles around. The owners are extremely knowledgeable about their inventory as well. Highly recommend. Because the store is so huge, if youre looking for something, theres a 99% chance theyll have it or something like it.

Jessee Taylor I had to take a moment to share the incredible customer service I’ve experienced at JLewis Jewelry—not just once, but multiple times over the years. Back in 2021, my husband bought my engagement ring and had an appraisal done . Fast forward to 2025, and my ring unfortunately went missing. Filing an insurance claim with Allstate (wouldn’t recommend) has been nothing short of a nightmare. Thankfully, Jill at JLewis Jewelry stepped in to help. She kindly provided a new appraisal right away, and when the insurance company rejected it, she went the extra mile to get me a detailed estimate for a replacement—even though it was time-consuming and totally outside of her obligation. She didn’t have to do any of it, but she did—with such grace and kindness. That’s rare to find these days. The quality of their jewelry and their customer service is truly unmatched. I’ll be coming back to JLewis Jewelry for all my diamond and gold needs. If you’re looking for a trustworthy jeweler, give them a try—you won’t be disappointed!