J. William Jewelers - Spencerport (NY)

Daniel Sciascia Scanlon Jewelers is a true gem in the Amherst, NY community. I’ve been a loyal customer for years, and their integrity, professionalism, and commitment to exceptional customer service are unmatched. Whether it’s engagement rings, men’s and women’s jewelry, watches, or expert repairs—Scanlon has it all. Brady Scanlon and Danny Duguay have always treated me with the utmost respect and care, making every experience personal and seamless. Their knowledge, honesty, and dedication set them apart. For anyone looking for a trusted jeweler, Scanlon Jewelers has my highest recommendation. Great work!!

Karlee Bensley Review #1: Amazing people and amazing service. They made a beautiful bracelet out of my mom’s shirt pins she had from bowling over the years. Would recommend them in a heartbeat! Review #2: Came back to get my grandmothers ring fixed (she passed in 2018). It was so important to me that someone takes special care of it and fixes it properly as it means too much to me. Couldn’t be happier. It is so gorgeous and they did an incredible job!!! Thank you so much!!!

ronald gebhard I met with Donna Hill-Nugent at this beautiful location to discuss melting down some old jewelry. Donna was extremely knowledgable and patient in explaining the process. She looked at every piece and handled them with great care. Donna took her time and in the end, I was very surprised and happy with the results. I highly recommend Charles Krypell if you are considering trading in your gold for cash. The entire staff was extremely friendly, the store is beautiful and Donna will see to it that you leave confidently, knowing that you made the right decision. Don’t wait.

Kelsey Tillman I can’t say enough good things about Alexis Russell Jewelry! The quality of their pieces is absolutely stunning — you can tell every detail is thoughtfully crafted. What really sets them apart, though, is their incredible customer service. A special shoutout to Gaby, who went above and beyond to help me with questions about resizing. She followed up every step of the way and made the entire process feel so personal and stress-free. I’m beyond happy with my experience and will definitely be a returning customer!

Jim NYC Very pleasant and helpful staff. Had an antique ring resized. They were able to do it while I waited and the price was very reasonable.

Amanda Iadevaio Great shop in town. Perfect for gifts or a gift for yourself. Lots of local goods and info. A must visit

B Paige Big Ben Jewelers did an absolutely amazing job creating my custom wedding ring using an heirloom ring which belonged to my grandmother. Anthony demonstrated amazing skill and expertise, melting down the original ring and using the existing diamonds (plus adding a few more) to create the perfect ring for me. They truly took their time with my family, ensuring the sizing and style was perfect for us. My mother and husband spent time consulting with Suzie and Anthony to ensure the ring was completed prior to our trip abroad. Thank you so much Suzie, for making sure my ring was done before our trip.. even having the ring expedited. The quality of the work completed was invaluable and Big Ben offered extremely reasonable prices for their high quality stones and services. I highly recommend Big Ben Jewelers & their team.. especially Suzie and Anthony. Thank you!

Mike Barlowe Picked my daughter up from college & she brought me in here. Beautiful place, unique items with a warm friendly atmosphere. It had Practical Magic movie vibes. The shop owner was very kind and helpful. I suggest checking this place out!

Ayesha Ahmed Excellent service! I bought two pieces and I had an amazing experience, the staff is so welcoming and helpful. Not rushing me at all and helping me find exactly what I was looking for. Will definitely be coming back for more!!!

Genesis Castro 10000/10 recommend this jewelry store! Noemi and the rest of the staff are incredibly kind and helpful. They will make you feel like anything you’re looking for is possible. They can get exactly what you’re looking for or even have it made! I am absolutely in love with the engagement ring and bands we’ve purchased from here and will continue coming to them for all of our jewelry needs. This is your sign to come to this store! You will not regret it. :)