Eastern Numismatics Inc - Garden City (NY)

5 /5 Nicole Votta: Frank was great. I had a bunch of coins not knowing if they were really worth anything. He went over each one and explained what each one was and what it was made of. I was completely satisfied and didnt feel like I was being taken for a fool.

5 /5 Costa Sarantakos: Stopped by with a coin collection I have had since my early 20’s and have had for many, many years. I worked with Joe who was truly quite knowledgeable and patient as it took about 1 1/2 hours to go through the coins and come up with something that was both fair to them and myself. After an agreeable price and handshake a check was given to me which was deposited the next day. Overall a low stress and pressure experience with a nice outcome for both I believe.

5 /5 Marianne Dowbak: Went to eastern numismatics after my jeweler recommended them so that I may get a fair price for 2 small serving pieces of sterling silver and some silver coins. I was very pleased with this establishment and most especially Eugene, who gave me what I felt was a very honest and fair evaluation of the value of my items. I highly recommend!

5 /5 Jay T: I had a wonderful experience visiting this family owned establishment. I met with Eugene who quoted me a fair price when selling them a few silver Britannias. He was extremely friendly and so was his brother Anthony and their staff member Lori. It’s quite a large store and they have a wide variety of collectible items they buy and sell. I left there feeling so good in how well I was treated. What comes to mind is a warm. super friendly vibe akin to a Bed and Breakfast. You can think of them as the Bed and Breakfast ofJewelry stores. I give them my highest recommendation. -J

5 /5 Karyn Cohn: I’m the kind of person to read reviews, and this was my first visit to Eastern Numismatists. I felt comfortable and right at home. My dad left me coins I knew nothing about, the value, the age, the significance or history. Joe sat down with me in a comfortable office and gave me a history lesson…a timeline of sorts, which related to world events as it related to the production of coins, the silver and gold content, the weight, and the age, and I witnessed an incredible machine which miraculously determined the percentage of metal in each coin. I was learning. I had also had fun. The coin values were explained, the profit margins, melt value, rarity.. and time invested to sell a coin, made me fully appreciate how much this family business meant to Joe. He was honest in his assessment. I’ll be back. with additional jars of coins to go through, but will see them in them in the concept of history.