Oldest City Insurance - St. Augustine (FL)

Gela Endicott Michelle has handled our auto policy for years. We wouldnt consider using anyone else or another company. Shes always helpful and makes sure you are totally satisfied.

jgradym Grady Went there when I decided to change my supplemental health insurance provider. Given lots of good advice, shown options and was not rushed. Very nice talking to a real local person face to face instead of some random salesperson in a call center. Very happy with my new insurance company.

Olivia Noelle Rodger was patient, kind, professional and provided top notch customer service. Thank you for helping me maximize my benefits and lower my monthly payments to a very affordable rate! Anyone looking to get the best car insurance coverage at the best price, I encourage you to speak with Rodger!

Chris Wimmers I have been using this agency for twenty years for home/auto/boat and would never even think about calling any other agency. The service here is outstanding!

Stephanie Prezzemolo Alexandra “Allie” Horblitt and her whole team (including Zack) are absolutely AMAZING! They have been helping me for years now and just recently I was at the DMV and after waiting for several hours it turned out I needed to change my insurance policy completely in order to reinstate my license and I called Allie and she took care of it immediately and was able to fax it to them and I was able to take care of everything and without Allie and her team it wouldn’t have been possible. Highly recommended, very professional, very efficient and I wouldn’t dream of going or working with anybody else!

Demmoy Lewis We cannot say enough great things about Shellie Warner! She went above and beyond to help my wife and me secure the best home and flood insurance rates. Her expertise and dedication were evident from the start. Shellie patiently answered all of our questions, walked us through every detail, and made what could have been a stressful process incredibly seamless. She truly cares about her clients and ensures they get the best coverage at the most competitive rates. We felt completely confident in her guidance and appreciated her prompt communication throughout. If you’re looking for an insurance agent who is professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping you, Shellie is the one to call. Highly recommend her services!

Danielle Brinn Lauren has been amazing from start to finish. Personable yet professional. Our insurance was lowest through them and they have been nothing but good to us. Would 100% recommend to everyone !

Tamika Gallimore I had a great experience while shopping around for insurance. I worked with Kaye. She was very professional and helpful. She offered great feedback and options to help me find the right policy for me. 10/10 recommend.

Sophia Lupinetti Maria was so amazing! Got me switched over from geico so fast. I procrastinated for so long & she still always answered and remembered me. Once I finally made the move I was paying $680 with geico now I pay $340 with progressive…. Same numbers. She made it fast & easy. Super sweet. I definitely recommend

Brian E All my insurance needs for the last 27+ years. Best prices, real good people