3 /5 Mike Lichtenfeld: The owner was friendly, but the initial offer I received was significantly below market value. When I declined and got up to leave, they attempted to renegotiate. About an hour later, I received a text offering $1,000 more than their original offer—still well below what I received elsewhere. I ultimately sold the items for nearly $2,000 more than their “best and final” offer.
In contrast, the jeweler who earned my business was upfront, honest, and didn’t play games. His valuation was spot on, and his offer reflected true market value. It was clear he wasn’t trying to make an excessive margin, unlike this store. I strongly recommend getting at least three opinions before selling—accepting this store’s first offer could cost you thousands, as it almost did for me.
