WhitsonLaw PLLC - Elizabethtown (NY)

1 /5 Sarah Marie: If you’re looking for an attorney who respects your privacy, communicates clearly, and operates with integrity—look elsewhere. Not only does this attorney charge 2.5x the average rate in the area, but the office is poorly managed and careless with sensitive client information. The most serious issue I experienced: my entire mental health and medical records were mistakenly faxed to the opposing party—a party the court had already ruled would not have access to those records. Despite that, the documents were sent anyway. It took twelve hours for the office to even realize the mistake, and to this day, I have never received confirmation that my records were retrieved or destroyed. They initially blamed the facility, but after further investigation, it was clear the error originated from her office—a mistake that could have easily been avoided with proper procedures and attention to detail. There was no accountability, no real apology, and no effort to take responsibility. This was not just a clerical error—it was a complete failure in client confidentiality and professional duty. I’ve taken time to reflect on this and spoken to other attorneys to ensure I wasn’t reacting emotionally, and everyone agrees: this kind of breach is indefensible. I have submitted a formal complaint with the AGC but in the meantime, the least I can do is share my experience to help prevent this type of misconduct from happening to another vulnerable client. Do not trust this attorney with your case or your personal information. There are plenty of professionals who charge fairly and operate with the care and ethics every client deserves.

5 /5 Leisa Santy: I cant say enough positive things about this firm during my divorce proceedings. This was a very scary process for me based on my circumstances, and I always felt they were there for me from the start! Wendy Hernandez and Katie Short were my contacts during the process, and they always had quick responses whenever I had questions or concerns. Never did I have to wait for a response. Debra Whitson, who was my lawyer that represented me in court was so professional and she was prepared for the judge. She is a classy lady on top of that! Thank you Wendy, Katie, and Debra for getting me over one of the hardest things Ive had to go through. Your compassion is unforgettable. You listened to what I wanted, which was very important to me! If you are looking for a good divorce team, consider Whitson Law.

5 /5 Tomar Alston: My Attorney, Wendy Hernandez and the team were super supportive to me. I was very grateful for their patience and professionalism while handling my divorce. I would definitely recommend this firm to anyone going through a similar situation.

1 /5 Linnae Hamilton: ABLEIST. Refused to consider my request (per the Americans with Disabilities Act) to accommodate my disability. Debra is a poor communicator, condescending and always too busy to answer within 48 hours. She made my mediation process so much more difficult and unpleasant that I decided to drive 2 hours away to a better lawyer. It was definitely the right choice!

5 /5 Bethany Mandy: Trying to find a decent lawyer is hard…finding a good lawyer, even harder! But finding a team of exceptional lawyers? A true rarity! I never planned on needing legal services, but unfortunately life had other plans. Luckily, when I did need help, Whitson Law was there to provide protection to help keep myself and my loved ones safe. Making sure you are hiring the best representation is crucial when having to navigate the legal system. I can honestly say, I have never experienced anything quite like the team efforts of Lawyers, Debra Whitson, Michael Paulonis, Wendy Hernandez and senior paralegal Jessica McNatt. I walked out of the court room - stunned! Investing in the right legal team, is ultimately investing in you. Make sure you know your worth.

5 /5 Leisa Santy: I cant say enough positive things about this firm during my divorce proceedings. This was a very scary process for me based on my circumstances, and I always felt they were there for me from the start! Wendy Hernandez and Katie Short were my contacts during the process, and they always had quick responses whenever I had questions or concerns. Never did I have to wait for a response. Debra Whitson, who was my lawyer that represented me in court was so professional and she was prepared for the judge. She is a classy lady on top of that! Thank you Wendy, Katie, and Debra for getting me over one of the hardest things Ive had to go through. Your compassion is unforgettable. You listened to what I wanted, which was very important to me! If you are looking for a good divorce team, consider Whitson Law.

5 /5 Bethany Mandy: Trying to find a decent lawyer is hard…finding a good lawyer, even harder! But finding a team of exceptional lawyers? A true rarity! I never planned on needing legal services, but unfortunately life had other plans. Luckily, when I did need help, Whitson Law was there to provide protection to help keep myself and my loved ones safe. Making sure you are hiring the best representation is crucial when having to navigate the legal system. I can honestly say, I have never experienced anything quite like the team efforts of Lawyers, Debra Whitson, Michael Paulonis, Wendy Hernandez and senior paralegal Jessica McNatt. I walked out of the court room - stunned! Investing in the right legal team, is ultimately investing in you. Make sure you know your worth.

1 /5 Sarah Marie: If you’re looking for an attorney who respects your privacy, communicates clearly, and operates with integrity—look elsewhere. Not only does this attorney charge 2.5x the average rate in the area, but the office is poorly managed and careless with sensitive client information. The most serious issue I experienced: my entire mental health and medical records were mistakenly faxed to the opposing party—a party the court had already ruled would not have access to those records. Despite that, the documents were sent anyway. It took twelve hours for the office to even realize the mistake, and to this day, I have never received confirmation that my records were retrieved or destroyed. They initially blamed the facility, but after further investigation, it was clear the error originated from her office—a mistake that could have easily been avoided with proper procedures and attention to detail. There was no accountability, no real apology, and no effort to take responsibility. This was not just a clerical error—it was a complete failure in client confidentiality and professional duty. I’ve taken time to reflect on this and spoken to other attorneys to ensure I wasn’t reacting emotionally, and everyone agrees: this kind of breach is indefensible. I have submitted a formal complaint with the AGC but in the meantime, the least I can do is share my experience to help prevent this type of misconduct from happening to another vulnerable client. Do not trust this attorney with your case or your personal information. There are plenty of professionals who charge fairly and operate with the care and ethics every client deserves.

5 /5 Tomar Alston: My Attorney, Wendy Hernandez and the team were super supportive to me. I was very grateful for their patience and professionalism while handling my divorce. I would definitely recommend this firm to anyone going through a similar situation.

1 /5 Linnae Hamilton: ABLEIST. Refused to consider my request (per the Americans with Disabilities Act) to accommodate my disability. Debra is a poor communicator, condescending and always too busy to answer within 48 hours. She made my mediation process so much more difficult and unpleasant that I decided to drive 2 hours away to a better lawyer. It was definitely the right choice!