STARLITE JEWELRY - Shirley (NY)

Brittany Ballish Lucio and Laura are absolutely amazing! My husband and I used them for our engagement, wedding rings and wedding earrings and Battisti went above and beyond anything we could have expected. Both my husband and I had some particular thoughts in mind yet we were unsure of how to convey these ideas exactly at first. Both Lucio and Laura were so patient and worked closely with us to design such beautiful pieces that were beyond anything we had imagined or originally hoped for. This is custom jewelry with excellent client service and care at it’s finest. Battisti’s has been a family jeweler on my husband’s side for a while and even though we live in Phoenix now, we can honestly say we’ll never use anyone else.

Nadine Ive known Joe and Ina for many years, from when they were in Forest Ave, flea market! They both will go out of their way to make you feel welcomed. They truly have a unique shop, lots of vintage jewelry, I think thats what drew me to them in the first place, nothing is same ole same ole. I was so happy to see theyre still in business on New Dorp Lane, since Ive been off the island for over 8 years. I travelled to them from upstate NY to get my granddaughter a piece of jewelery for her 18th birthday and graduation. As soon as I walked in Ina remembered me, we had some nice conversation and a pleasant shopping experience! As always they are 2 very fine people along with their son Gary, and Im so happy we were able to do business! Thank you so much, I will only buy from your shop. Happy to see you both, Nadine

Barbara Roth Billy is one of the nicest people in this business that I have had the pleasure to do business with. He has a great selection of quality jewelry, with the knowledge to back it up. I will continue to make Polara Jewelers my go to for all my wants and needs. The pricing is fantastic. Billy is a honest, class act and a pleasure to know and do business with!

Mirna Sanchez If you need help with ...anything. Better not with this customer service.

cindy peters Robert is amazing! He is such a joy to work with he goes above and beyond to make his customers happy . I have a picture of Robert putting in a pictures of my mother and father into the locket that I had bought from him . What a Guy ! He is honest to the tee & his prices are amazing . I can’t wait to go back to the store to see what new antique jewelry he has gotten it . . Thank you Robert

S S Guy at the front was super helpful in helping me find a Mother’s Day gift. Highly recommend this place!

Keysha Bastien My son got his ear pierced here

Chuck Boise Dave fixed my wifes watch and she is happy

M S Excellent customer service. Brought in a watch where I had changed the battery but couldnt get the battery cover to reseat/seal. The person behind counter took it into the back room and returned

Jenny Echevarria I purchased I chain wit charm. It’s beautiful I was helped by Aneidy customer service was A1! And I will be coming back for more purchases! Please come and shop with Aneidy