Maguire Family Insurance Agency - Ithaca - Ithaca (NY)

Reilly Dodd Incredible customer service! The team goes above and beyond to guide you through the complexities of the insurance process. Everyone in the office is genuinely kind and courteous. I’m especially grateful to Shawna for checking my renewal options with Progressive during our call and following up with helpful info on other policies. I truly appreciate her support. Fantastic team—thank you all for your help!

Luis Morelos Making a claim was easy and straightforward. The support team was helpful and made the whole process stress-free. Would definitely use this service again

DRE LEMAR Great place to do business

Lori Ann Langworthy Katie and the girls handle all of my needs quickly and professionally. I can stop in whenever I am in town and they handle everything. Love my team !!

John Denecke From her warm and welcoming manner, and throughout the entire process, I cannot say enough good words about Danielle Fugate. She is a true proefessional, and she not only helped me find a better offer, but also gave me sound advice and guidance moving forward. It is because of Danielle and her excellent customer service that will have me coming back to FREEWAY for all of my insurance needs. With appreciation and kind regards, John

Marc Osmun After leaving Progressive Insurance we were looking for a much better insurance company that would combined both our home and cars together at a rate we could trust to be there when needed... That was/is The Insurance Place in Fulton where Heather set us up with Erie Insurance years ago and we couldnt be happier today. Whenever I call Heather its as if we have been friends for years. She is always so friendly yet so very good at her job, giving us the feeling she cant do enough for us each and every time we call. You should give her a call too!

Lynda Defoe I worked with Karen and she was wonderful. She was quick to get back to me with a quote. It was cheaper than my prior insurance company. She was friendly and answered all my questions.

Bridget Riley Giacalone Insurance is the ABSOLUTE BEST!! The girls in the office are the nicest, friendliest and are very knowledgeable and helpful in every way. I dont mind paying my bill in person because they are a fun group.

Estelle McCumber Nice to do business with

Sam Phillips I was in a tight spot and needed new insurance quickly. Maurice helped me out, even working on a Saturday to make sure I had everything I needed. He went above and beyond and got me set up insanely fast. Definitely would recommend!!!!