Maguire Family Insurance Agency - Ithaca - Ithaca (NY)

Butch Yager I couldnt be more satisfied with my insurance people! They all are right there to assist and Jessie treats me like family and has my back 24-7. When I call she delivers!! I give them 5 STARS !!!

Rob Hofstetter Mr. Warren took the time to explain in great detail what I was actually purchasing. He offered me a different plan that was much cheaper than what I was considering. Jamie made the whole process seem so easy compared to my last agent. I have recommended him to my friends and family. Thank you Jamie and staff and may God Bless.

Irina Petrik Rita Hawkins and her team are truly the BEST. What an outstanding professional! Rita works promptly, offers immediate solutions and always goes out of her way to accommodate her customers. To top it all off, she does it with a smile on her face. Such a fantastic human being. I feel lucky to have such a great State Farm agent. Highly recommend!

Erin Roosa Robert was so helpful, as a new car owner everything is so stressful and complicated and he did everything to make it as simple as possible. He gave me everything and more than what I was hoping for. Very good experience and if you’re looking for simplicity and good customer service he is the perfect person for help and a great company!

steven chustckie Exceptional Service from Richie, Bianca, and Steven I wanted to take a moment to recognize the incredible service I’ve received from Richie, Bianca, and Steven. They have all been absolutely amazing—professional, responsive, and truly dedicated to providing the best possible experience. I can’t believe how happy I am with the service I’ve received. It’s rare to find a team that goes above and beyond the way they have. I’m genuinely grateful and wanted to make sure this was acknowledged. Thank you for having such a great team.

Jocelyn Gaïty This company does a great job making sure to provide you with exactly what you need. They go above and beyond helping you understand your coverage and going that extra mile to make you feel secure in what you have.

Vlad Loenko Extremely fortunate to have found an agency that actually CARES about me as a customer. As someone who shops around, I was able to effortlessly find competitively priced insurance with the help of the lovely ladies who work here! When life is chaotic, insurance is the last thing on my mind. Sarah and the David H. Wager insurance group goes above and beyond to ensure I’m up to date on my coverage and payments. They did all the hard work behind the scenes to make sure I had coverage for what I needed. Anytime I have questions it’s a quick call or text, they’re extremely responsive and thorough; Elizabeth has been able to help during a vehicle transfer and additions/revisions to my policies. I’m happy to continue bringing my business here, and whenever I walk into the office I feel welcome like a family. They’re always doing local events, so if you see them at throughout Victor say hi!

Joseph Siracusa Best experience I have ever had with an insurance company. Nick and jason are top notch and know there stuff. Not only did they guide me to the proper insurance needed but also saved money on the policy as a whole. The best part is I get one bill monthly with all things included for the multiple house policy. Everything is on auto pay which makes it easy. I would definitely recommend their company to whoever is looking for a one stop shop for all of their insurance needs

Bathsheba Plaisted When I was shopping around for auto insurance, I was pleasantly surprised by the comprehensive coverage Legacy Insurance Agency NY offered at such an affordable rate. I was initially skeptical, thinking there might be hidden fees or that the customer service would be subpar. However, after a year with them, I can confidently say that they provide outstanding value. I’ve had no issues.

Terrance Depreta JoAnn and Erin have been fantastic! All the ladies on staff are always there with answers when called, very professional and polite as well. The Decker Agency always as the customers best interest first and foremost saving them lots of money!! Now how can you argue with that. Highly recommended