Grimsley Agency of NY - Canastota - Canastota (NY)

Patrick D Swan Great company with personalized service. Extremely professional and responsive. I highly recommend for all insurance needs.

Jason Macuch I have been a client for 18 years. Josh and Jim have always provided the best service in the industry with competitive rates. The Macuch Agency holds my entire insurance portfolio. You would benefit by calling them to quote your insurance needs.

Suri Antonio Rachel took the time to walk me through each policy option and helped find everything to my needs. I had many questions and she was so patient. I feel confident in my coverage now.

Michael Cappy I helped a friend of mine search for a vehicle after hers was totaled out. The check they cut her was a dishonest low-ball. The comparable vehicles they used were over 3 hours away. They gave her 1800 for a 3k vehicle. She called about the offer and they agreed to up it a few hundred dollars ( which she was happy with). Once the check finally came it was the original low ball offer. After weeks of waiting and missing out on several vehicles. All her calls have been ignored. Shame on Robert Amey or Anthony Day for taking advantage of a young woman!!! One of them offered her more and one of them sent the lower. the worst part about it was getting the title to them so they can sell the totaled car at auction. Horrible experience and she was forced to buy a car that doesnt even come close to what she had. The one screenshot below is the upped offer they never sent.

Ronald Bennett I have been dealing with Dan for over 20 years and have found Dan and his staff to be excellent. They are knowledgeable, courteous, helpful and always answer any questions I have, even calling me back promptly if they have to check something out first. The rates they charge for coverages are most competitive. Also, they gladly give excellent advice when asked. What more can you ask for????

David Zhushma Highly recommend! Called and talked to Jordan, and was able to get several policies quoted. Jordan took his time to find the right policy that worked for our needs, and was very responsive for any questions we had.

Able Ponce I’ve been with State Farm for several years now, and it’s hands down the best insurance for anyone to want and have. Agents such as Steve always go the extra mile to make sure you are well taken care off. Give them a call! you won’t regret it!

Alyssa Marchinek I cant say enough good things about Hutchings Agency Inc. and Douglas Hutchings Jr.! When on the hunt for car insurance Douglas was my first call. He answered all the questions I had, provided me with multiple quotes and ran through the specifics of each one in great detail. He also encouraged me to shop around for other rates, which I did. I reached out to numerous companies and no one came close to Douglas’s rates, coverage and customer service. After speaking to so many companies in such a short timespan, it was extremely clear to me why Hutchings Insurance Agency has such a great reputation in Orange County, New York. They are intent on providing objective guidance and helping people find the best deals even if it means not making the sale. That is such an awe-inspiring business philosophy, especially in this day and age! Anyone looking for honest, principled and informative advice from experts in the Property and Casualty Insurance field should not hesitate to reach out to Douglas and his team!

Fay Travis I knew it was time to switch insurance providers, so I did my homework and asked around. Most people pointed me to RPK for general liability insurance. Well, now I understand why! Every interaction has been smooth and successful, and I never wait long for answers. This is exactly how insurance should be done. My compliments!