Curabba Insurance Agency - Middletown (NY)

Natasha Hemmings I have been a customer for 4 years,and I have nothing but wonderful experiences with A E insurance agency! The owner is knowledgeable, professional, ethical and informative, he is my go to when I need insurance advice and Im never disappointed. He is great at what he does, which makes his expertise more appreciated by me. Will recommend this agency to anyone who needs insurance whether its commercial, business, personal you name it he got it!!!!!

Josh I work in the car business and can say I have assisted clients in thousands of insurance changes over the past decade plus and I must say calling into this office has been the most pleasant experience for a mutual client I have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. Cybil who answered the phone was attentive from the get go in assisting with a complex situation for her client. Cybil went above and beyond even though we were less than a half hour before the agency closed for the evening. She got us the required documents flawlessly the first time and in such a quick manner I was SHOCKED. I will be referring clients to this office and am personally going to be calling them to try and give them my personal business for auto/home. All I can say is wow....Thank you so much on behalf of us at the dealership and our mutual Client!!

Valeria S. I was overwhelmed comparing plans but Sophia walked me through step by step. She found a better deal than the other agents I spoke with.

Shawn Bei I can’t thank Paige, Russell, and Maureen, and the entire team enough for their incredible support throughout my wedding insurance claim process. From the very beginning, they were responsive, helpful, and genuinely understanding. With their help, my claim was approved, and I was able to recover $11,500 in deposits that I had initially thought were lost. They made what could have been a stressful and overwhelming experience feel straightforward and manageable. Paige contributed to making sure everything stayed on track, and I truly appreciated her efforts. It’s rare to come across a firm that provides this level of professionalism and care. The communication was clear, the process was well-explained, and I felt supported the entire time. Everyone I interacted with went above and beyond to make sure I was taken care of. I would absolutely recommend this firm to anyone needing insurance assistance. Their compassion and dedication really stood out, and I’m incredibly grateful for their help. Thank you all again for turning a difficult moment into a positive resolution!

Frank Denchick Jim and staff are extremely professional, responsive, and friendly. Ive always had great service, and the best value for my money.

Danailyn Nuñez Just had a great experience with this insurance agency. The team helped me switch my coverage and the entire process was hassle free. They were friendly, professional and gave me a great rate. Very satisfied customer.

Barbara Auerbach Easy to reach—always respond quickly—friendly and polite—price actually went down this year!

Gabrielle An agent signed us up with this horrible company we never liked them but dealt with it. Over the weekend we received a letter from sterling stating they will not be renewing our policy because 1) we have too many dogs and the guy taking the pictures of our house was terrified of my black and tan coonhound, my hound was in a fenced in area of our yard. The guy also deemed my dog aggressive because my dog was barking at him. My dog was barking at a stranger on our property my hound was doing his job. Next the roof had some moss on it because the sun never hits that side of the house and the guy was here before spring cleanup. The moss is gone and lastly possible woodstove yes there was a woodstove but we removed it years ago however the chimney for it is still here however its capped inside the house. We had sterling for over a decade and zero claims but they still dropped us. Good riddance to a garbage insurance company. Look no Woodstove just a capped off chimney I love the generic response. NO, I will not to be touch just so I can be annoyed all over again that ship has sailed. We already had another company come out to get pictures and even better the kind lady isnt afraid of dogs. She walked right up to the fence and pet all of my dogs they licked her hands. Here is a final edit: I did call back to see if this could be resolved and spoke with Elaine apparently if you admit you dont like the agent Sterling puts you with they drop you for that reason. Its kind of like being in middle school only worse because were adults. Im thrilled that we are now insured with one one of the top 10 homeowners insurance companies in the United States. I found this company on my own no agent needed

Joey Fiscolare Signing up for Medicare is a very arduous process, between figuring out when to sign up, what to sign up for, all the different parts and plans, all the different rules, all the different prices and all the different types of coverage. Craig Smith simplified this process for me and answered all my many, maybe sometimes silly questions, with patience. His wisdom and experience really helped me through the process of signing up and I now feel very comfortable with the choices Ive made with Craigs help. I would highly recommend Craig to anyone who feels intimidated by the whole Medicare sign up process. He makes it simple and makes you feel comfortable and confident in your choices.

Steven Vensky Kathy & Tyler are very friendly and extremely knowledgeable on how to save you $$$!