Best luxury jewelry shop 2025 in New York, USA - (NY)

Marjorie Charles Just visited the store today after my friend recommended them. Staff was friendly and helpful. I got my daughter lovely 22 karat gold studs. Ill be back when my budget allows. Do call the store first because an appointment is normally required. This practice allows personalized attention and ensures security given their priceless merchandise.

Raven Malfetano Papas Gold City is family! I’ve had the pleasure of working with Papas for almost 10 years! Their service is 10/10! If you want it they have it, and if they don’t have it- they can make it! Chris, Michelle, Zo, Christina, and the whole gang are true professionals. I will be getting jewelry from them for years to come!

Kir If any shop deserves a BIG 5 star review its Jasons!! I dropped by on a whim looking for wedding bands for myself. He has a great selection at great prices! I loved the first one I put on, although it was several sizes too small. Jason was attentive, gave feedback, and was so accommodating - he is able to resize in ONE day. I went home and told my fiancé exactly where to go and what to get. Unfortunately, we were moving from NYC to CA that week and he never made it to Jasons. I went to several stores in CA trying to find something, but nothing compared to the ring from Jasons. Nervous with my big day approaching, I called Jason to see if he could overnight the ring to CA. He answered right away, got the ring resized and shipped the next day!! It was received with plenty of time in perfect sparkly condition. Jason, thank you from the bottom of my heart for helping fulfill my wedding dreams. I will always love this wedding band story!

Kelcey C My boyfriend and I dropped in, looking to see if they had star sapphires available. We were interested in getting an engagement ring. The staff had one available, but it didnt suit me. Jon spoke with us and let us know they make custom jewelry. We decided to give it a try. I sent in some photo ideas of what I wanted. Jon put a rough design in front of us based on what I sent. They have special software that can render a ring on a screen. It gave us a good idea of what we wanted. We sat with Jon making adjustments until we were happy with what we had. Jon then had a 3d print of the ring made. He brought in samples of different star sapphires for us to look at and with the 3d print, we could see it come together. Once we finalized the details we had the ring made. I was extremely happy with the result. I feel that I have such a unique and special ring. The fact that Jon was able to take our ideas and make such a beautiful piece of jewelry made us so happy. The staff was all so sweet and helpful. I cant say enough good things about this store. We plan on purchasing another ring for my boyfriend. I also want to get some other pieces for myself. They have such a wonderful selection. Cant wait to go back!

Geri Smith Very satisfied does a beautiful job kind and courteous he knows his stuff

Stephanie Lee High quality jewelry, handmade locally and the owner is the sweetest. You can really see his passion and hard work in his pieces. They have jewelry for both men and women. Definitely recommend if you are looking to get something nice for yourself or as a gift. Support local businesses!

Angela Ruggiero Love love love! Have been coming here for as long as I can remember. They are honest, trustworthy and very friendly. Dee is great, always gives the perfect recommendations based on what youre looking for and keeps your budget in mind. They have a great selection in store and if you cant find exactly what you want they will seamlessly modify or custom order/ create what you want. I have gotten multiple pieces here and all are great quality ! I never have any doubts when coming here, highly recommend.

M L jeff and linda are refreshingly genuine people. my husband and i stopped in for a jewelry repair and were not disappointed. absolutely delightful turn around time and the price was more than fair. we are thrilled to have found a new jeweler--one that is honest, knowledgeable, and genial. so happy with the repair, the shop, and the fun customer service!

YahConni Johnson Purchased for my granddaughter and it was exactly what was advertised and the price was great too. Plus it came earlier than expected.

Aneu Twenty I had jewelry that I was not using anymore and trusted it to Eduardo and his very capable Coworkers. I wish I had a picture of what I gave him to fully appreciate the masterpiece he created. Looking forward to my second project.