Best luxury jewelry shop 2025 in New York, USA - (NY)

Shari Hayden Just needed links taken out of a watch. Very kind women in the store. They had nice jewelry there too!

Catherine O I LOVE the elegant emerald and diamond half eternity ring that I received today from Sarahs. The ring is spectacular, re-sized perfectly, and shipped in gift boxes!!! Superb customer service, very fair pricing and a ring that is so elegant. I give Sarahs Vintage & Estate Jewelry my highest, most enthusiastic recommendation!!

Jess Hamm My daughter and I decided to get silver anklets for her 16th birthday. We love them! 1 week later they are staying strong and no tarnish whatsoever! Highly recommend Jen and her permanent jewelry! Best price and quality in the area!

Mr. Sir Superb shipping department. Very kind and accommodating to drivers. We need more places like this

Steven Lee Ive known Tim since I was a kid...Hes a great guy and a very fair owner. Great deals, clean store n a wonderful selection. He is very kind to Veterans as well...

Denisse Guillermo Uhh this place is amazing. Idk what the one lady was talking about. The people there always respect their customers and are absolutely professional. Best experience Ive had fixing my watch and I even bought a necklace from them just cause I had such a nice experience. They have a dog named bananas whos also quite the gentleman and interactive with the customers. Love this place.

Ryan Waldo Got some beautiful pieces for my girlfriend here. The staff was very helpful. Everything looked even better after they polished it. Also, had them clean and polish my ring and it has never looked better. Everything is very reasonably priced

George Collins Great store. Very professional staff, nice and polite, helped me going through my questions, gave me a lot of useful advice on picking jewelery. I repaired a ring and a watch here, as well as purchased a pendant. Flawless experience every time.

thomas rodriguez Number not in service and it’s closed

Shelly Warner I stopped in the West Village location this weekend to make my first Gorjana purchase. I wanted a necklace for my birthday and a Miss Kate assisted me in finding the right necklace and length as I am very tall, etc. I found one that I absolutely love and she was very sweet and helpful. Highly recommend!