Potter Insurance - Pontiac (IL)

A Altabarani Im thrilled with the Cotter Allstate agency. Their team demonstrates outstanding expertise, deep knowledge, customer-focused dedication, and an unwavering commitment to assisting customers. Especially my experience with Elizabeth has been fantastic; she combines extensive experience with genuine care. I couldnt be happier with this agency. Thank you so much!

Jaiden Patel I love your kindness

Bonnie Lenz Derek got us quotes right away and set up with the insurance we needed quickly (as I had waited last minute) and smoothly. Great service! We are repeat customers for a reason!

Ryan Cullen Ive been insured by Shelter Insurance for 5 years now, I have vehicle, motorcycles, Life and my business all covered. Brandon has been great about explaining what I am paying for, what I getting in return. Along with keeping me up-to-date on any changes on my policies.

Anabel Morales I was coming from an insurance agency. I would only hear from once a year. I connected with Jose who was very kind and flexible with me around my schedule to be able to set up an appointment. Jose connected me with Maribel as she was a best fit for my schedule to meet and talk about insurance for homeowners and auto. From the first call all the way to signing the documents. She has remained professional, friendly, kind and caring. I could not think of a better team to take care of me and my needs and go into detail so I could also understand what it is that I needed as well as how I was going to be covered. Thank you so much to the American family insurance, this has been such a seamless process as my first time switching insurances since owning my home and auto.

Kayla Schauer Sophia was a big help in enrolling my new vehicle onto my policy and made sure I got everything taken care of with my Drive Safe & Save. She even followed up a few days later to make sure everything went smoothly. This office is always so helpful and honestly the best rates for insurance I have found.

Ivy OvO Good customer service and they helped me keep my payment low compared to other companies.

Carla Brinkoetter My husband and I have had our home and car insurance with Amanda for many years. The service she provides is the absolute best. She is always just a phone call away. I had a car accident while in Florida and all I had to do was call Amanda. She set everything in motion to get my car repaired as quickly as possible. Amanda cares about her clients and it shows!!!

Jason Damico I started working with Mandys office before I relocated from NY. My main interactions have been with Kelsi as she has guided me through auto, homeowners, and life insurance policy updates. Ive had insurance through either State Farm or another provider for almost 20 years and worked with several offices, but the level of support Ive had here stands out. Mandy has a great team. I read through the reviews before choosing her office and sometimes you think "too good to be true?" when you see a perfect rating. Well, so far in my experience, it is true. Great staff, great support. Cant see myself anywhere else.