Lillia Jewelers - Eureka (IL)

Dave B If I could give these folks a hundred stars I would. Neena and Ray earned our trust a few years back when we had some estate jewelry to let go. A friend recommended them to us at the time and we couldn’t believe how honest and personable they both were. We returned to have some custom jewelry made recently and were again blown away by their impeccable business etiquette and honesty. They listened to what we wanted and went above and beyond to satisfy our expectations. Neena’s has earned our loyalty for future business and we have no reason to shop anywhere else. You will find unmatched quality and fair prices and dealing directly with the owner of the business is by far the best way to get what you’re looking for. Give them a try!

David Rudolph Mateusz and the jewelers at Studio D literally rock! Always blown away with the quality, professionalism and attention to detail that they effortlessly share with each piece and each visit we had with them. I would change this rating to 10 stars if the app would allow it. Thank you so much Studio D team! Can’t wait for our next jewelry project with you all!

tyler williams Great guy awesome to talk to takes pride in his work got a nice chain and hoping to get a lot more from this amazing shop 10/10 go here lovely people

Mayra G Great selection and really nice staff! I came out with more that I needed lol

Kary Martinez I couldn’t be happier with my custom-made ring from Dalzell Jewelers! I shared my vision, and they brought it to life perfectly. The rose-cut center stone sparkles brilliantly, and the addition of my kids’ birthstones makes it incredibly personal and meaningful. The sleek bezel setting is both secure and elegant. Kim guided me patiently through every step, making the entire process seamless. Truly a wonderful experience. I’m now a loyal customer. Highly recommend!

Sydney Hopkins Jessica was so helpful! From cleaning my ring to showing my husband and I the perfect wedding band! Definitely can’t thank her enough!

James Caruso From the inception of our first visit as a couple to Costello Jewelry Company . . . to the very present—just days after our wedding—Trisha has worked with us every step of the way and has made our entire customer experience BEYOND extraordinary and beyond exceptional. We were fortunate to not only work with the best of the best, but we discovered in Trisha a person who has the highest integrity and an even bigger heart! Here are the words to describe our experience at Costello with Trisha and her character: Personable, professional, an eye for the “right contextual fit” for the customer and their needs, affable, caring, encourager, great communicator, beyond helpful, pleasant to be around, amazing, a joy to work with and speak with, and the list goes on. We were also blessed to have met Maureen, who was a great, great encourager and supporter alongside Trisha. Trisha and Maureen have helped to take our relationship with Costello jewelers to new Heights. I, James, have been a customer of Costello Jewelers going back 1998 and now a customer with Katherine for the last eight years as a couple. I want to give a special shout out to Jose who has been at Costello as long as I’ve shopped there. I see that gifted artisan working with amazing skill and artistry every single time I’ve been to Costello. He is one of the main individuals who helps to create and refine the jewelry that the Costello customers have come to know and love. Where would an exceptional jeweler be without an extraordinary artist like Jose? We are so grateful to the Costello family for their fine locations and even finer business and hospitality. We always appreciate their family and spiritual values and always love the meaningful mailers we receive, especially at Christmas time!

Hailey Stark I absolutely love this shop! a must visit when you are in the area! I also love the Mystik Markets that are hosted here!

Peggy Maria Simpson provided a great experience to me in July, 2025. She greeted me with excitement and when I explained what I was looking for, she immediately pointed me in the right direction. The first piece she showed me was the one I ended up purchasing for a bridal gift. She showed me exactly what I was looking for and did not pressure me in any way. She was kind and professional. I dont shop for much jewelry these days, but definitely will return to her when I do! Thank you Maria, the piece ended up being perfect!