5 /5 Mark Bradshaw: I just completed my annual comparison analysis for my auto, home and umbrella coverages and American Family Insurance came out on top again. I compared them to Allstate, Farmers, and State Farm. My AFI agent searches for every discount that he can find, and he has managed to keep my rates as low as possible and better than the competition. I have had no issues with AFI, and I trust them to continue to provide me with the best insurance bundle available. I would recommend this particular agency to anyone looking for superior insurance coverage.