Direct Auto Insurance - North Fort Myers (FL)

Pam We have used Your Choice Insurance over the past 5 years. No other insurance company in Florida has come close to the quotes they have given us!! The agent Arvin was hands down THE BEST!!! Very professional, kind and helpful. Arvin went above and beyond to make sure all of our insurance needs were met. If you want more than a quote, if you want personal service, an agent who cares and outstanding customer service then you want your insurance with Your Choice Insurance!!! Customer service is OUTSTANDING WITH YOUR CHOICE INSURANCE!!! Amber the owner treats her customers as family not just insured!!

Incognito Outstanding Insurance Agency! The customer service is impeccable! Liz has extremely driven work ethics and is a Grand asset to this company. I am grateful for all of the assistance she and Travis continuously provide for my company!

Angelique C Aubrey Jones helped me get coverage for my new home. As a first time home buyer AND buying an older home that was hard to get affordable coverage, Aubrey was able to find me coverage and at an affordable rate. She made the process very easy, explained everything to me in a way I understood, and overall gave fantastic customer service. She also helped me save money on my existing car insurance as well. I would absolutely recommend her in general, but especially if youre unfamiliar with obtaining insurance and want help from someone you can trust.

Heather I had such a great experience with Mack! I’m currently with Progressive, and honestly, what I’ve been paying for car insurance there is just ridiculous, but that’s beside the point. From the moment I spoke with Mack, he was friendly, understanding, and had a great sense of humor. It truly felt like talking to a friend rather than just someone doing their job. He made the whole process easy and comfortable, and I never felt pressured. I highly recommend going to see him for all your insurance needs. Mack made it a genuinely great experience!

Brian Muniz Ariel & Lleliena go above and beyond! Goes out of their way and finds the best way to save money.

Mary Glynn The Thompson Insurance Agency is the best. Brian Thompson was responsive and knowledgeable. After Ian, the filing of claims was very complicated. Just now in 2025, Brian’s looked over my insurance for the condo. He found., I had a check for &2,000, that I over looked. Job well done. I would recommend them to anyone.

Paula Kemp Anytime Ive ever had questions or concerns, Dave, Tammy and others in the office are always quick to get us the answers we need. Dave figured out my insurance company at some point added my 10 Y/O to the policy and fixed it. When the policy renewed, they did it again. Tammy contacted them personally to make sure it didnt continue to happen after I was getting nowhere with them on the phone. She was my champion fighting for me that day against the big guy!

Frank Rodriguez Fantastic staff, great rates. Super happy with my insurance!!