Blue Sophia Jewelry - Key West (FL)

Nadia Barnini Absolutely love this local shop. Beautiful custom pieces, great prices, and quick with repairs! I showed them a picture of a setting I found online and they were able to recreate it for a fraction of the price. I bring my husband’s chain in frequently and they fix it for me on the spot. Definitely worth stopping in if you are shopping for something new or want to spruce up something old! I sent my friend in for a repair of her wedding band and she was equally as impressed. Go check it out for yourself!

space charizard Came in to get the band of my citizen dive watch repaired and the very helpful staff addressed and repaired the issue while I waited. I fully expected to have to drop it off and leave, but they went above and beyond. I was in the store for less than 15 minutes. I would definitely recommend this business services to anyone who ask.

Michael Stanley Angela and Carolyn were amazing. They helped me pick out my wife’s new wedding ring. They were patient and thoughtful through out the whole process. They got her exactly what she wanted and pictured. They even helped me pick out more ideas for Christmas and birthdays that were uniquely my wife. I will recommended them to everyone I talk to for jewelry.

Maria Lewis This store has everything and then some!! A lot of unique items!! They have crystals, wind chimes, clothing and just about anything metaphysical you can think of! If youre in the Tallahassee area, you definitely need to check this place out!! The staff is very friendly and informative!! I purchased mullein there!

Katie Hilbert I can’t say enough good things about Amy and the rest of the team at Pickett Brothers! Even in the face of something completely unexpected—when an inclusion appeared in my engagement ring’s stone during a routine cleaning (a rare fluke and absolutely no fault of the jeweler)—they went above and beyond to make it right. From the very beginning, they were transparent, communicative, and incredibly empathetic to how much sentimental value my ring holds. Amy kept me informed every step of the way and made sure I felt supported through the entire process. Not only did they source a replacement stone that matched mine perfectly, but they also preserved the original one and had it set into a beautiful pendant for me to keep—a gesture that meant more to me than I can put into words. Their care, attention to detail, and genuine compassion turned what could’ve been a heartbreaking situation into something truly meaningful. I’m so grateful for the experience and would trust them with any piece, big or small.

Françoise Mugnano I came in needing something fixed right away before I travelled back home and they were very friendly and helpful in figuring out a quick solution for my broken chain. While I waited, I wondered if they had anything to make my ring tighter and they were able to also offer something to hold it tighter. Excellent service and very friendly! Couldn’t recommend more.

L P My husband and I visited this store today (Thursday afternoon) for the first time in the nearly 2 years that weve been in Florida and we were pleasantly surprised by the variety of items under one roof. There is plenty to look at from umbrellas in wine bottle-shaped cases to hand-crafted jewelry to useful (and ornamental) home goods. There is a large price range. The bigger artisan glass centerpieces are obviously not for anyone with a modest budget, but if you know the work that goes into that art, I can understand the price tag... We were only supposed to be browsing while waiting for our order from Cheesecake Factory, but a pair of custom socks at the stand next to the counter caught my eye. The gray socks had "Worst Gift Ever" embroidered onto them next to a sad-looking sock sitting on steps. I decided that those would be PERFECT for a Dirty Santa gift exchange at work. (I was right - the gift recipient LOVED them!). I also bought motivational stickers to add to my holiday cards for decoration and a kitschy alligator pin for the lapel of my jacket. At the checkout counter, I met the owner, Paula, who was very friendly, informative, and efficient. She even neatly gift wrapped the socks (how thoughtful!) since I mentioned that I was bringing them with me to my holiday office party later that afternoon. I will definitely be visiting this store again for gift ideas and to see the new seasonal items that Paula displays the next time were in town. Ill tell my friends about this place so they can enjoy the interesting variety that this gift shop carries. Thanks for making our first visit a pleasant and memorable experience!

Barbara Greenfield What a wonderful experience! Its great that they have a number of services for your jewelry in one place - its not just a store! And the sales people are really nice and accommodating. My sales person was Jamie, and she patiently answered all my questions and spent a lot of time with me. Im definitely going back!

juan molina I have to say my experience was great Javy was an excellent salesperson and was able to help me get what I wanted at a great price when I receive my chain. It was exactly what I was expecting. It looks beautiful. Javi Made it very easy for me to get approved and also make the correct decision. I definitely recommend this place 100%. I definitely will buy here again. Thank you! Javi we talk soon.

Brian Kelley This place is amazing! Went in to have a bracelet fixed and was treated like royalty. The owner couldnt be nicer. This place is a gem. Beautiful store with some fantastic offerings. My new "Go To" place for everything jewelry. The bracelet repair was above and beyond what I could have asked for.