Alls Cheap Car Insurance - Staten Island (NY)

5 /5 Malachi Jason Jason: I had an amazing experience with Alls Cheap Car Insurance! They truly live up to their name by offering the best cheap car insurance without sacrificing quality. The team was friendly, knowledgeable, and made the whole process fast and stress-free. I saved a lot of money and got excellent coverage. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for affordable and reliable car insurance options!

5 /5 porter harry: I didn’t expect my first car insurance policy to be this simple. On the way back from Miller Field, I saw All’s Cheap Car Insurance right on New Dorp Lane and decided to stop in. Being a new driver, I assumed budget-friendly auto insurance might mean less coverage, but they proved me wrong. They walked me through liability vs. full coverage, explained the deductible in plain English, and gave me a monthly premium I could actually afford without losing protection. I walked out with my proof of insurance the same day, smiling like I’d passed another exam. They even shared advice on keeping rates low over time. Finding a team this kind and helpful is rare, so I’m sticking with them for renewals.

5 /5 Rachel Mellow: Alls Cheap Car Insurance offers a professional and efficient service experience. They provided me with several well-explained options and helped me secure cheap car insurance that fits both my coverage needs and budget. I highly recommend their team for affordable and trustworthy insurance solutions.

5 /5 Bryce Noah: Finally, an insurance office that doesn’t treat you like a number.” That’s exactly how I felt leaving All’s Cheap Car Insurance on New Dorp Lane. Hosting on Airbnb means I needed auto insurance that covered me properly but stayed affordable. My old company had me lost in deductible talk and hidden fees, but here they actually explained the difference between liability and full coverage in plain, simple terms. And the cost? Way less than I expected. They gave me a quote that felt like real budget-friendly car insurance, not a ripoff. I ended up with more coverage for less money and a monthly premium I can live with. Proof of insurance in hand, I left with relief — and their number saved in my phone for renewals.