Local Color Jewelry Store - Key West (FL)

Eva Shoop My daughter was gifted the beautiful seahorse petite choker which quickly became her favorite piece of jewelry. She was devastated when she accidentally broke the necklace, but after we collected the pendant and as many beads as possible, Dina generously offered to restring the necklace for us, replacing the missing beads. Each piece of Be the Light jewelry is stunning and such a unique, special gift. Just as importantly, you cant beat the exceptional customer service!

Nicholas Wheaton took a cluster of calcite I found in Arch Creek to get mounted into an earring. I was nervous since calcite is very soft, but David and his team pulled it off! Im very pleased to have had a local jeweler handle this local treasure.

Paul If you need jewelry appraised and/or have a jewelry stash of questionable valuable, Reynolds and Co. Jewelers is the place to go! I spoke to twelve stores who review and appraise jewelry in the central Florida area and decided on Reynolds and Co. due to their substantial experience with all types of jewelry, having a graduate gemologist onsite and very reasonable rates. Owner David spent a significant amount of time with us reviewing our jewelry. David provided insights on each piece and was very patient answering our many questions. At our request David provided candid recommendations and was never pushy to make a sale or steer us in a disadvantageous direction. Susan expertly performed appraisals on a number of pieces generating a document containing pictures, detailed information and a value assessment of each. Susan’s highly comprehensive analysis identified unknown information on a few of the pieces, ironically never noted in previous appraisals from other stores. Reynolds and Co. also sized two rings (expertly matching an intricate design so one could never tell!) and made a highly creative suggestion combining parts from two of our pieces with exceptional results. Thank you David and Susan, you are a blessing!

juan molina I have to say my experience was great Javy was an excellent salesperson and was able to help me get what I wanted at a great price when I receive my chain. It was exactly what I was expecting. It looks beautiful. Javi Made it very easy for me to get approved and also make the correct decision. I definitely recommend this place 100%. I definitely will buy here again. Thank you! Javi we talk soon.

deborah fejza Nick has been AMAZING. I bought two pair of chrome hearts glasses from east coast and they are absolutely amazing company. They were very responsive and helpful in what I was looking for. They are all amazing and tell everyone to go there. I don’t live in Miami and they still made it easy for me to shop over the phone and online!!

David Kurz Cliff and Mike are the best! I trust them 100%. Have bought several Rolex watches from Mike and Cliff is a master jewelry.

Natalia Novak STEVE was amazing! Such a great experience. I was on a very difficult timeline to repair expensive medical loupes and another office sent me to Bartons Jewelry. I really needed the repairs done same day. So instead of putting me in a position where I had to close my practice to wait for the repairs, Steve humbly got the job done using the best equipment and 30 years of experience. Cant say enough how appreciative I am. Thanks Steve.

Nicole Rodriguez We had such a great experience at this location and Lorenny assisted us in exactly what we were looking for! Aside from having beautiful and unique pieces, their attentiveness was amazing. Will be coming back for future purchases!

Traci Brooks I love this place because of the sweet couple. Theyve helped me with several jewelry needs, batteries for watches, I bought a really awesome vintage Betty Boop watch for my daughter AND the alterations Ive had for me and my oldest daughter are done with such a professional quality that it reminds me of my moms work being she was born in the 1930s. I highly recommend! Thank you!