Carats Fine Jewelry & Watches - Sarasota (FL)

Holly Lambrechts Pamela was incredible to work with. I needed help with a trade and a design for a ring . She provided excellent suggestions and she had a large selection to choose from. I was very happy with the results. I highly recommend this beautiful and friendly store.

luis hernandez Excellent job fixing one of my silver chains. Juan Carlos y Lorena were very helpful and professional. I would definitely come back and highly recommend them.

Michael Stanley Angela and Carolyn were amazing. They helped me pick out my wife’s new wedding ring. They were patient and thoughtful through out the whole process. They got her exactly what she wanted and pictured. They even helped me pick out more ideas for Christmas and birthdays that were uniquely my wife. I will recommended them to everyone I talk to for jewelry.

Skin Care Guru I recently had the pleasure of doing business with Asi, co-owner of Golden Bay Jewelers. I am very particular with my jewelry purchases, and Ive found Asi to be professional, patient, kind and accommodating during every step of the process of customizing a 2-piece lab created diamond wedding ring Set, comprised of a 5ct TW 3-stone ring, a complementary high-carat eternity band, and a 13.75 ct tennis bracelet. All turned out to be spectacular and more impressive than expected! Beautiful clarity, tremendous sparkle and shine, all-around! I receive so many compliments on a daily basis! In addition, I also plan to buy a 4ct set of stud earrings and soon upgrade one of my Rolex watches to a larger-faced model with this jeweler. I highly recommend Asi and his family at Golden Bay Jewelry for all of your jewelry needs!

Paul Herber This jewelry store and the people who work here are absolutely amazing! I received so much help from JD with my purchases that I felt I really needed to give a shout out, and thank him (them) all being such a great business. No wonder it has been a successful business in Naples, FL for over 35 years. I strongly recommend this local store.

Joan Ford The prongs holding the diamond on my engagement ring were bent and I was afraid of losing the stone. Robin greeted us warmly and asked how she can help. I told her that the prongs werent aligned properly to hold the diamond securely. She had someone fix it for us right away, and for free.

Alexandra Rudnick We had a custom ring designed at Underwoods, and the experience was fantastic from start to finish. Deonna was incredibly helpful, patient, and knowledgeable, guiding us through every step of the process. The final piece turned out even more beautiful than we imagined. I would absolutely work with Underwoods again and highly recommend them to anyone looking for exceptional custom jewelry.

Emily Layt Thanks so much to Madison, who helped me with purchasing my very first Tiffany necklace! Her kindness and graciousness were the cherry on top to help make my checkout experience that much more special and that much more easy! Thank you!!

Lisa Armstrong Every associate is top notch. Theyre friendly, knowledgeable and helpful without being pushy. My engagement ring and two wedding bands were purchased at this store. And I am definitely going to be a lifelong customer for any future purchases. The only downside, I wish they had an in-store shop for repairs. I have issues with my ring finger knuckle and its been a process trying to get the sizing right. And having to part with my rings for 10-14 days. No fault of the associates! I just think there is definitely a need for repairs to be done locally at the store.